Question
Q:Debbie and Veronica, who had never married but had lived together for approximately six years, were in the process of ending a stormy relationship. When
Q:Debbie and Veronica, who had never married but had lived together for approximately six years, were in the process of ending a stormy relationship. When Debbie arrived at home that night, she discovered that many of her personal belongings had been destroyed, the interior of their home "trashed," and the phone ripped from the wall. Debbie told the police that she then went into the kitchen and that when she arrived, Veronica physically attacked her and slammed her into the stove.
Debbie told the police that she grabbed a kitchen knife, stabbed Veronica in self-defense and hadthen gone outside to "cool off." When she thought that the fight was over, and that it was safe togo back inside, she returned to the kitchen. She discovered a trail of blood leading from thekitchen through the living room and out onto the front porch where she found Veronica collapsed face-down on the porch. She alleges that she rolled her over. Veronica was unresponsive. Debbie alleges that she found Veronica's car keys in one of her pockets, got in her vehicle, drove to a friend's house several miles away, and called her mother. Debbie does not claim that she personally contacted medical or law enforcement personnel; rather, authorities were apparently
summoned by Debbie's sister-in-law, sometime within an hour after the stabbing. Debbie did return, however, to the trailer home where she waited for the deputies and medics to arrive. On December 3, 2022, Debbie was charged with negligent homicide for causing the death of Veronica by stabbing her once in the chest. Although she admitted stabbing Veronica and causing her death, Debbie entered a plea of not guilty based on the defense of justifiable use of force.
On December 15, 2022, shortly before the scheduled trial date, the prosecutor filed an amended indictment charging the same offense but alleging that Debbie caused the death of Veronica by stabbing her once in the chest with a knife and by failing to call for medical assistance. Debbie again entered a plea of not guilty.You are a prosecutor in the state of Jamaica where the common law applies.
Write a memo to your supervisor explaining the best arguments convicting Debbie of negligent homicide for her failure to call for medical assistance.
Step by Step Solution
3.50 Rating (153 Votes )
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Subject Legal Analysis and Strategy for Convicting Debbie of Negligent Homicide Dear Supervisors Name I am writing to provide an analysis and strategy ...Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started