Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

QUESTION 1: Multi Attribute Utility Theory The infrastructure manager of a road maintenance company needs to prioritize maintenance for 22 bridges that are in

image text in transcribed

QUESTION 1: Multi Attribute Utility Theory The infrastructure manager of a road maintenance company needs to prioritize maintenance for 22 bridges that are in need of repair based on four criteria. He is confronted with the constraints of limited budget, network availability and safety, among many others. Moreover, the infrastructure manager wants to perform maintenance only where he can minimise the owner costs and maximise the object's reliability level. Such a decision-making problem requires the assessment and selection of alternatives (i.e. bridges), where a trade-off among the objectives can be made and most of the constraints can be met. The data provided from the road transport agency included description of the twenty-two bridges in terms of bridges' age, geometry, condition index on the element level, traffic intensity, planned maintenance activity on the element level, unit cost of chosen maintenance option, and maintenance duration. For this illustrative application of MAUT, the twenty-two bridges are required to be ranked based on the following 4 criteria's: (a) Condition Index (CI) (b) Owner Cost (OC) (c) User Delay Cost (UDC); and (d) Environmental Impact (EI) The score obtained for each bridge using the available data for each criteria is presented in the Table 1. Table 1: Score of each alternative for each criteria No. Bridges Name Attributes UDC EC 1 Bridge A 2.77 139.35 39.70 0.86 2 Bridge B 1.89 126.41 27.50 0.21 3 Bridge C 2.15 115.67 25.57 0.57 4 Bridge D 2.73 42.94 3.41 0.02 5 Bridge E 2.00 68.16 12.40 0.53 6 Bridge F 2.12 149.21 47.89 0.23 7 Bridge G 2.10 169.56 57.79 0.48 8 Bridge H 2.42 88.60 13.11 1.25 9 Bridge 2.22 45.82 35.89 1.26 10 Bridge J 2.34 115.93 30.80 0.43 11 Bridge K 2.42 39.42 12.69 0.23 12 Bridge L 2.46 69.61 12.12 0.03 13 Bridge M 1.92 38.14 7.99 0.03 14 Bridge N 2.18 84.89 14.42 1.05 15 Bridge O 2.43 46.89 4.59 0.00 16 Bridge P 1.67 175.33 28.51 0.68 17 Bridge Q 2.08 161.48 55.25 0.37 18 Bridge R 2.30 158.89 51.04 0.22 19 Bridge S 2.58 65.90 8.79 0.10 20 Bridge T 1.96 62.22 22.83 0.42 21 Bridge U 2.02 84.82 25.70 0.28 22 Bridge V 2.34 152.60 42.91 0.27 The manager has also analysed the raw data and established the following utility function for each criteria: Utility function for Cl: U(xi) = 1.26-13.72* e-xi/0.7 Utility function for OC: U(xi) = 1.00 -4.13 * e-xi/27 Utility function for UDC: U(xi) = 1.00 -1.34* e-xi/14 Utility function for EC: U(xi) = 1.08-1.09 * e-xi/0.5 Additionally, the infrastructure manager has assigned the following weights to each criterion to reflect their relative importance: CI = 0.29; OC = 0.32; UDC = 0.14; and EC = 0.25. By using the information provided in Table 1 and the utility function, rank the bridges using MAUT approach.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Essentials of Management

Authors: Andrew J. DuBrin

9th Edition

538478233, 2900538478235, 978-0538478236

More Books

Students also viewed these General Management questions

Question

Write out the first three terms in the expansion (x + y) 12 .

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

What is the biggest challenge facing the organization?

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

What is quality of work life ?

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

What is meant by Career Planning and development ?

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

What are Fringe Benefits ? List out some.

Answered: 1 week ago