?Question $1$

$$ ?Peterman Inc. provides an automobile to Ms$.$ ?Winters for her to use in carrying out her employment duties.

$$ ?Ms$.$ ?Winters is given full possession of the car and is allowed to use it for personal needs. However, when she is not using it for employment or personal activities, it must be returned to Peterman$$s premises so that it can be used by other employees.

$$ ?The automobile was purchased in $2019$ ?for $$42,000$ ?and, during the years $2019,2020,$ ?and $2021$ ?the Company has deducted maximum CCA.

$$ ?During $2022,$ ?Ms$.$ ?Winters drove the car $52,000$ ?kilometers, with the Company paying for all of the operating costs. These costs totaled $$11,350$ ?during the year.

Required: Ignore all GST$/$PST$/$HST implications. Indicate the minimum taxable benefit that would be allocated to Ms$.$ ?Ms$.$ ?Winters in each of the following Cases:

Case A Ms$.$ ?Winters has use of the car for $11$ ?months of the year. Personal use during the year totals $8,000$ ?kilometers.

Case B Ms$.$ ?Winters has use of the car for $9$ ?months of the year. Personal use during the year totals $15,000$ ?kilometers.

Case C Ms$.$ ?Winters has use of the car for $7$ ?months of the year. Employment use during the year totals $9,000$ ?kilometers.