QUESTION 1:

When Chris was 18, his father Peter told Chris "I promise to give you $5,000.00 if you don't smoke until you are 21 years old". Chris agreed, and they put the agreement in writing. With the support of Meg and Brian, Chris managed to stay smoke free. At his 21st birthday party, after a few beers, Chris tried to collect from Peter, who refused to pay.

1. If Chris were to sue Peter, on what legal theory of recovery would he most likely sue?
2. Is Chris' promise to refrain from smoking adequate Contract Consideration? Why or why not?
3. Do you thinks Chris would win ?

QUESTION 2:

In July, 2009 Ryan Howard of the Phillies' hit his 200th career home run, having achieved that milestone in fewer games than anyone in major league history. 12 year old Jennifer caught the historic, and obviously valuable ball. Jennifer was at the game with her 15 year old brother. A Phillies' team representative convinced Jennifer to exchange the ball for one that was worth only $100, and some candy.

Jennifer's parents sued the Phillies to rescind (undo) the agreement, asking the Court to return the ball to Jennifer.

1. What Contract issues are presented by this case?
2. Do you think Jennifer should win? Why or why not