Questions Do you think the employer should be entitled to dismiss Mr. Keays without giving him reasonable
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Questions
- Do you think the employer should be entitled to dismiss Mr. Keays without giving him reasonable notice? Explain why.
- Does an employer have a right to insist that employees submit to medical examinations by doctors chosen by the employer? Explain why.
- If the doctors inform the employer that Mr. Keays’s absences are due to his chronic fatigue syndrome and that they are likely to continue in the future, should the employer be entitled to dismiss Mr. Keay’s? Explain why.
- If Mr. Keays wins his wrongful dismissal case, will the court order Honda to reinstate him to previous employment? Should it do that?
Transcribed Image Text:
Honda Canada Inc. v. Keays, [2008] Mr. Keays was hired in 1986 by Honda as an assembly-line worker. In 1997 he was discharged with chronic fatigue syndrome and consequently went on disability benefits until the insurer declared that he was fit to return to work. When he returned, the employer put him into its disability program, which required him to submit medical reports for every absence from work. The employer began to doubt the veracity of Mr. Keay's doctor's reports and, therefore, in 2000, ordered him to see a doctor it had selected. Mr. Keays obtained legal advice recommending that he not see the employer's doctor unless the employer clearly indicated the purpose of the examination. The employer ignored the lawyer's request and summarily dismissed Mr. Keays for cause (without notice) when he refused to meet with the employer's doctor. The employer claimed that this was insubordination, entitling it to dismiss Mr. Keays without notice. Mr. Keays sued for wrongful dismissal. He argued that his employer did not have a contractual right to force him to attend a different doctor chosen by the employer simply because the employer did not like opinion of the employee's own doctor. Therefore, he was not being insubordinate by refusing an order that the employer had no right to make. Moreover, he argued that the requirement to submit to a medical examination by the employer's doctor amounted to harassment and discrimination on the basis of his disability and was part of a conspiracy between the employer and the doctor intended to enable the employer to dismiss him for cause after doctor issued a report saying Mr. Keays was able to work. Therefore, he argued that in addition to reasonable notice damages, he should be entitled to damages for bad faith in the manner in which he was dismissed and to punitive damages to for the employer's egregious conduct. Source: Belcourt, M., Singh, P., Bohlander, G. && Snell, S. (2014) Managing Human Resources (7th ed.) Toronto, ON: Nelson Education Ltd. Honda Canada Inc. v. Keays, [2008] Mr. Keays was hired in 1986 by Honda as an assembly-line worker. In 1997 he was discharged with chronic fatigue syndrome and consequently went on disability benefits until the insurer declared that he was fit to return to work. When he returned, the employer put him into its disability program, which required him to submit medical reports for every absence from work. The employer began to doubt the veracity of Mr. Keay's doctor's reports and, therefore, in 2000, ordered him to see a doctor it had selected. Mr. Keays obtained legal advice recommending that he not see the employer's doctor unless the employer clearly indicated the purpose of the examination. The employer ignored the lawyer's request and summarily dismissed Mr. Keays for cause (without notice) when he refused to meet with the employer's doctor. The employer claimed that this was insubordination, entitling it to dismiss Mr. Keays without notice. Mr. Keays sued for wrongful dismissal. He argued that his employer did not have a contractual right to force him to attend a different doctor chosen by the employer simply because the employer did not like opinion of the employee's own doctor. Therefore, he was not being insubordinate by refusing an order that the employer had no right to make. Moreover, he argued that the requirement to submit to a medical examination by the employer's doctor amounted to harassment and discrimination on the basis of his disability and was part of a conspiracy between the employer and the doctor intended to enable the employer to dismiss him for cause after doctor issued a report saying Mr. Keays was able to work. Therefore, he argued that in addition to reasonable notice damages, he should be entitled to damages for bad faith in the manner in which he was dismissed and to punitive damages to for the employer's egregious conduct. Source: Belcourt, M., Singh, P., Bohlander, G. && Snell, S. (2014) Managing Human Resources (7th ed.) Toronto, ON: Nelson Education Ltd.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 No I do not think an employer should be entitled to dismiss Mr Keays without reasonable notice because all provinces and also the federal jurisdiction have employment standards legislation providing ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Managing Human Resources
ISBN: 978-0176506902
7th canadian edition
Authors: Monica Belcourt, Parbudyal Singh, George W. Bohlander, Scott Snell
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
1. Do you think the employer should be entitled to dismiss Mr. Keays without giving him reasonable notice? 2. Does an employer have a right to insist that employees submit to medical exams by doctors...
-
Does an individual have a right under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) to sue the United States for injuries suffered in a foreign country regardless of where the tortious act or mission occurred?
-
Do you think the balance-sheet channel of monetary policy would be stronger or weaker if: a. Firms balance sheets in general are very healthy? b. Firms have a lot of existing variable-rate debt?
-
Wollongong Group Ltd, of New South Wales, Australia, acquired its factory building about 10 years ago. For several years the company has rented out a small annex attached to the rear of the building....
-
Ridgecrest Company manufactures plastic storage crates and has the following information available for the month of April: Required: Using the weighted-average method of process costing, complete...
-
\(\frac{231}{490}\) Reduce the fraction to lowest terms.
-
Elfrink Co. began year 2005 with 6,300 units of product in its January 1 inventory costing $35 each. It made successive purchases of its product in year 2005 as follows: The company uses a periodic...
-
Aglow Inc. manufactures entry and dining room lighting fixtures. Five activities are used in manufacturing the fixtures. These activities and their associated activity cost pools and activity bases...
-
There are 9 green apples and 6 red apples in a basket. (a) What is the ratio of green apples to all apples in the basket? (b) What is the ratio of red apples to all apples in the basket?
-
Cybernetronics Inc. (Cyber) is a Canadian-owned public company which designs and manufactures communications and control systems. The company's year end is May 31. It is now June 2018. You, CPA, are...
-
Share a Stress Management Strategy : Share a stress management strategy or technique that you find effective or interesting. Describe the strategy without tying it to personal stressors. You are not...
-
QUESTION 1 (5) (5) 1.1 Briefly discuss the field of study concerned with the flow of energy through living organisms, and the two basic laws that govern biological energy transformations. 1.2...
-
In an engine, a piston oscillates with simple harmonic motion so that its position varies according to the expression x ( t ) = 18.0 cos( 25.0 t ) where x is in centimeters and t is in seconds. (a)...
-
Discuss the three major branches of biology ? who is the father of the botany.?
-
A mole of an ideal gas is initially at 10 bar and 298 K. It is allowed to expand against a constant external pressure of 2 bar up to a final pressure of 2 bar. At During this process, the gas...
-
How did the growth of unknown differences between the known bacteria on each plate ?
-
An analysis of the machinery accounts of Concord Company for 2024 is as follows: Machinery Accumulated Depreciation Machinery, net of Accumulated Depreciation Balance at January 1, 2024 $492000...
-
If the annual fixed costs are 54,000 dinars, the occupation expense represents 20%, the contribution margin is 25%, and the unit selling price is 40 dinars. Required: Calculate the closing point of...
-
Should compensation packages be equal across the world or should they be adapted to the local cultures and economies? In teams, debate each position.
-
1. Describe the advantages of the approach used to identify performance gaps. 2. Why would managers resist or support this approach? 3. Describe methods that you would use to evaluate the...
-
The Pay Equity Commission proposes three methods to make pay equity comparisons: The job-to-job comparison method The proportional value comparison method The proxy comparison method What are some...
-
College Textbook Publishers Inc. has prepared income statements segmented by divisions, but management is still uncertain about actual performance. Financial information for May is given as follows:...
-
All Things Greek Inc. has three sales divisions. One of the key evaluation inputs for each division manager is the performance of his or her division based on division income. The division statements...
-
Six Flags Theme Parks Inc. operates theme parks in the United States, Mexico, and Europe. One of its first theme parks, Six Flags over Georgia, was built in the 1960s in Atlanta on a large tract of...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App