Questions Presented: McKnown is suing Mr. Grieten. Mr. Grieten owns the car his daughter was driving. Under state law, is Mr. Grienten liable given the fact that his daughter exceeded his instructions regarding the use of the car?

Statement of Facts: On July 6, our client, Johann Grieten, gave his daughter, Joanne, the car keys and told her to drive to the shopping mall and purchase some paint. The mall is approximately eight miles from their home. He told her, "Go directly to the mall and come directly home. Don't, I repeat, don't go anywhere else. Don't go to your friend's house, don't go shopping." Joanne purchased the paint and returned home. Her father had gone to a neighbor's and was not home. He left a note saying, "I'll be back in a couple of hours." Joanne's friend Sally called and said, "You've got to see the new car my dad is going to buy me." As Joanne drove to the dealership to meet Sally, she failed to yield at a stop sign and collided with Jeffery McKnowns car Case Law: Jones r. Fleischhacker, 325 N.W.2d 633 (Minn. 1982).