Read the case below and answer the following questions.

Aintree University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust $($Respondent$)$ v James $($Appellant$)[2013]$ UKSC $67$

$1.$ CriticallyevaluatehowtheSupremeCourtarrivedatitsdecisioninthiscase. Support your discussion with evidence from the case including the interpretation of

statute, the use of precedent, and the approach to judicial reasoning. $(50\%)$