Scenario 1 Jean Claude is an owner of a reptile store A python escaped from its enclosure in the store through a ventilation duct, travelled to an upstairs apartment and killed two young boys who were sleeping in the room The snake tried to escape before, but it appeared to be larger than the diameter of the ventilation duct and Jean Claude did not think it could escape through it Should Jean Claude be held responsible for the boys' death If yes, why If not, why not (briefly explain what principled considerations guided you in your answer) Scenario 2 Due to momentary lapse of attention, a driver fails to negotiate a turn, mounts on a sidewalk, strikes and kills a pedestrian The driver was following all traffic rules, but took his eyes off the road for less than a second when the bottle fell at his feet while he was driving and he reached down with his right hand to pick it up Should we classify the driver's actions as criminal If yes, why If not, why not (briefly explain what principled considerations guided you in your answer)

The Answer is in the image, click to view ...

Answered step by step

Verified Expert Solution

Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Posted on Jul 03, 2024

Scenario 1: Jean-Claude is an owner of a reptile store. A python escaped from its enclosure in the store through a ventilation duct, travelled to

Scenario 1:

Jean-Claude is an owner of a reptile store. A python escaped from its enclosure in the store through a ventilation duct, travelled to an upstairs apartment and killed two young boys who were sleeping in the room. The snake tried to escape before, but it appeared to be larger than the diameter of the ventilation duct and Jean-Claude did not think it could escape through it.

Should Jean-Claude be held responsible for the boys' death? If yes, why? If not, why not? (briefly explain what principled considerations guided you in your answer)

Scenario 2:

Due to momentary lapse of attention, a driver fails to negotiate a turn, mounts on a sidewalk, strikes and kills a pedestrian. The driver was following all traffic rules, but took his eyes off the road for less than a second when the bottle fell at his feet while he was driving and he reached down with his right hand to pick it up.

Should we classify the driver's actions as criminal?If yes, why? If not, why not? (briefly explain what principled considerations guided you in your answer)