Summary of an Article related to Mutual Fund Performance. Grading Rubic Criteria for Assigning Article Review Grades Maximum Percent Maximum Points Content: Provides a thorough synopsis of the article. 43% 15 Analysis and Critical Thinking: Demonstrates knowledge of finance in explaining the authors results/conclusions. 23% 8 Analysis and Critical Thinking: Agrees or disagrees with the authors results and explains the position taken using sound finance theory. 11% 4 Writing Style and Grammar 23% 8