Suppose a stand-up comedian has a routine that involves her telling jokes about her Jewish mother-in-law and other Jewish relatives, and the contrasts or comparisons between her Jewish husband's family and herself as a black woman. And suppose some of the jokes include insinuating that Jews don't like blacks (such as saying that her mother-in-law, upon first meeting her, said to the father-in-law, "Eliot, put my purse away."). Now suppose the comedian's in-laws sue the comedian for defamation.

Who should win?