Tariq rented out his car to Amjad for three days @ Rs 3000/00 per day. The contract between the two dictated that the car is not to be driven outside the Karachi limits and to be driven by Amjad himself. Amjad let his brother drive the car on return from Hyderabad who gets into an accident with a truck. It is found out that the accident happened as there was no oil in the brake chamber.

The matter is in the court for damages, who in your opinion is likely to win/lose and why. Give detailed reasons for your answer.

B) What will be your answer if Amjad was driving the car himself and accident would have been on Tariq Road. Reasons of the accident remaining the same i.e. no oil in the brake chamber, which made the brakes malfunctional