Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

The assignment is to prepare a rough draft of the appellee's brief in opposition to the appellant's appeal of the trial court's denial of the

image text in transcribed
image text in transcribed
The assignment is to prepare a rough draft of the appellee's brief in opposition to the appellant's appeal of the trial court's denial of the motion to suppress evidence seized from appellant's suitcase. The plaintiff/appellee is the United States; the defendant/appellant is Arnold J. Stewart. The trial court ruled that the suitcase had been abandoned and, therefore, the defendant did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy protected by the Fourth Amendment in the suitcase. Numerous cases deal with the issue of abandonment of personal property, and an appellate brief usually would include references to at least several cases. This assignment is an exercise in preparing a very simple, single-issue appellate brief and is designed to acquaint students with the basic elements of such a brief. Therefore, when performing this assignment, use only the constitutional and case law presented in the assignment; do not perform additional research. Assume the cases have not been overturned or modified by subsequent court decisions. Follow the format presented in Section (V of this chapter. The caption is presented in the following text. Prepare a separate statement of the case and statement of the facts. Information necessary for preparing the brief follows. Note that the transcript pages (references to the trial court record) and docketing pages are referenced in parentheses. When drafting the brief, include the references to the record in the brief. References to the case and statutory law also follow. When citing the United States v. Jones case, use the citation instructions presented in Assignment 7. Facts: On October 15, 2012, Arnold Stewart arrived at the airport an hour and fifteen minutes prior to his scheduled flight. (Tr. at 6) He was going to visit a friend in Chicago. (Tr. at 7) He was carrying one suitcase that he intended to carry on the flight. (Tr. at 7) His flight was scheduled to leave from gate 9, but he decided to wait at gate 8 because it wasn't so crowded. (Tr. at 8) After a few minutes, he decided to get something to eat. (Tr. at 8) He approached Larry Holt, who was also waiting at gate 8, and asked if Holt would watch his suitcase. (Tr. at 8) Stewart did not know Mr. Holt. (Tr. at 8) Holt asked him how long he would be gone and Stewart replied, "Just a few minutes." (Tr. at 9) Holt said, "Well, ok." (Tr. at 9) Stewart then walked off. (Tr. at 9) Across from where they were seated were several coin-operated lockers where Stewart could have placed the suitcase. (Tr. 9-10) Stewart went to the food bar. (Tr. at 10) There was a long line, and he wasn't served for 20 minutes. (Tr. at 10) On the way back to his seat, he ran into an acquaintance and talked to him for several minutes. (Tr. at 10) He didn't return to his seat in the gate area for 45 minutes. (Tr. at 13) Meanwhile, after 20 minutes, Mr. Holt became concerned. (Tr. at 41) He thought, "Where is that guy? i wonder if this suitcase contains a bomb. " (Tr. at 41) The more he thought about it, the more concerned he became. (Tr. at 41-42) He contacted airport security and expressed his concerns. (Tr. at 42) Approximately a minute later, Officer Robert Dwyer arrived. (Tr. at 42) There was no nametag on the suitcase, no airline claim ticket attached, and no evidence of ownership on the exterior. (Tr. at 71) In such situations, airport policy is that the suitcase should be immediately inspected, then taken to the security office. (Tr. at 72) Officer Dwyer inspected the suitcase and its contents at the scene. (Tr. at 72) Upon opening the suitcase, he found a large bag that contained 40 smaller bags of a white powdery substance. (Tr. at 73) The substance was later identified as heroin. (Tr. at 122) The suitcase was taken to the security office and federal officers were called. (Tr. at 74) Approximately 45 minutes after he left, Stewart returned to his seat. (Tr. at 13) Holt informed him that he thought Stewart had abandoned the suitcase so he turned it over to airport security. (Tr. at 44) Stewart left the gate area, went to the ticket counter, and asked for information concerning the next flight. (Tr. at

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image_2

Step: 3

blur-text-image_3

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

International Business Law And Its Environment

Authors: Richard Schaffer, Filiberto Agusti, Lucien J. Dhooge, Beverley Earle

8th Edition

0538473614, 978-0538473613

More Books

Students also viewed these Law questions

Question

Wear as little as possible

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

Be relaxed at the hips

Answered: 1 week ago