Question
The Association for Innovative Technology (AIT) is a trade group funded largely by CodeX Corporation.During CodeX's antitrust trial, AIT was active in public relations as
The Association for Innovative Technology (AIT) is a trade group funded largely by CodeX Corporation.During CodeX's antitrust trial, AIT was active in public relations as it worked to convince everyone from the public to members of Congress that the antitrust case would thwart innovation in computers, software, and their uses.Joseph H. Feldman, chairman of Phoenix Corporation, a software manufacturer and fierce CodeX competitor, was concerned that the public might not understand that AIT was funded by CodeX and was not truly an independent group.Through Phoenix, Mr. Feldman hired Privacy Services (PS), a private investigation firm, to find information tying CodeX to AIT.Mr. Feldman described his hiring of PS as his "civic duty."Shortly after PS was hired by Phoenix, janitors working the night shift at the offices of AIT were offered $90-$100 each by Rosa Garcia, a woman working for PS, if they would turn over AIT's trash to her rather than dumping it.The janitors refused, and Ms. Garcia returned the next evening and offered them $600 each for the trash plus $400 extra to the supervisor if he could convince the janitors to cooperate.All of the staff declined the money.Ms. Garcia left them her card, explaining that she was working on a criminal case, and asked them to call if they changed their minds.When the janitors disclosed what had happened, the investigator was traced back to Mr. Feldman who said, "All we did was to try to take information that was hidden and bring it into the light.I don't think that's arrogance.That's a public service."Do you think what Phoenix, Mr. Feldman, and Ms. Garcia did was ethical? What ethical dilemmas are raised by this case? What ethical model would you use to analyze the case?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started