The Choco Corp. incurred the following costs in 2016:

Beginning direct materials inventory	$10,000
Beginning work in process inventory	$72,000
Ending direct materials inventory	$24,000
Ending finished goods inventory	$23,819
Direct labor cost	$24,000
Manufacturing overhead	$14,000
Total product costs	$70,000
Cost of goods manufactured	$96,000
Cost of goods sold	$130,000

What is the beginning finished goods inventory balance? (hint: use cost of goods sold formula)