The Department of Work and Pensions Minister announced the appointment of Erica Chowdhury as chair of the Health and Safety Executive. This was controversial because the Minister had ignored the recommendation of the committee responsible for vetting candidates that she was not suitable for the role as she lacked experience. Shortly after the appointment, a story appeared in the press stating that Ms Chowdhury's husband had donated 40,000 to the government party before the last election. When questioned about this by the Shadow Minister in the House of Commons, the Minister stated that he was 'totally unaware' of the donation.

Two days after this exchange the Daily Standard newspaper publishes a story including emails between the Minister and Mr Chowdhury in which the Minister thanked Mr Chowdhury for his 'generous and unwavering support'. These emails were sent before the appointment of Erica Chowdhury.

Is the conduct of the Minister compliant with constitutional rules (you should explain which rules are applicable here and how they shouldbe applied)?

Speak about conventions and how this scenario links to lord dicey