Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

The following question was given to Chatgpt. Determine whats correct, fix all the mistakes, and assign a Letter grade: A , B , C ,

The following question was given to Chatgpt. Determine whats correct, fix all the mistakes, and assign a Letter grade: A,B,C,D,F ?
Let's go through the problem as detailed in the image and relate it to our earlier discussion.### FOL Statement\[\alpha =\exists x (Q(a, x)\rightarrow P(x, a))\]This statement asserts that there exists some \( x \) in the domain such that if \( Q(a, x)\) is true, then \( P(x, a)\) must also be true.### Interpretation \( I_1\)(where \(\alpha\) is true)1.**Domain \(\mathcal{D}\)**: \(\{d_1, d_2\}\)2.**Interpretation \( I_1\)**: -\(a\) refers to \(d_1\)-**Predicate \(Q\)**: -\(Q(d_1, d_1)\) is true -\(Q(d_1, d_2)\) is false -**Predicate \(P\)**: -\(P(d_1, d_1)\) is true -\(P(d_2, d_1)\) is irrelevant since \(Q(d_1, d_2)\) is falseUnder this interpretation:-\(\exists x (Q(a, x)\rightarrow P(x, a))\) holds because we can choose \( x = d_1\). For \( x = d_1\): -\(Q(d_1, d_1)\rightarrow P(d_1, d_1)\) is true because \(Q(d_1, d_1)\) is true and \(P(d_1, d_1)\) is true.Therefore, \(\alpha\) is true \( I_1(\alpha)= T \) under this interpretation.### Interpretation \( I_2\)(where \(\alpha\) is false)1.**Domain \(\mathcal{D}\)**: \(\{d_1, d_2\}\)2.**Interpretation \( I_2\)**: -\(a\) refers to \(d_1\)-**Predicate \(Q\)**: -\(Q(d_1, d_1)\) is true -\(Q(d_1, d_2)\) is false -**Predicate \(P\)**: -\(P(d_1, d_1)\) is false -\(P(d_2, d_1)\) is irrelevant since \(Q(d_1, d_2)\) is falseUnder this interpretation:-\(\exists x (Q(a, x)\rightarrow P(x, a))\) does not hold because for \( x = d_1\): -\(Q(d_1, d_1)\rightarrow P(d_1, d_1)\) is false because \(Q(d_1, d_1)\) is true and \(P(d_1, d_1)\) is false.Therefore, \(\alpha\) is false \( I_2(\alpha)= F \) under this interpretation.### Summary-**Interpretation \( I_1\)**: - Domain \(\mathcal{D}=\{d_1, d_2\}\)-\(a\) refers to \(d_1\)-\(Q(d_1, d_1)=\text{true}, Q(d_1, d_2)=\text{false}\)-\(P(d_1, d_1)=\text{true}, P(d_2, d_1)=\text{irrelevant}\)-\(\alpha\) is true \( I_1(\alpha)= T \)-**Interpretation \( I_2\)**: - Domain \(\mathcal{D}=\{d_1, d_2\}\)-\(a\) refers to \(d_1\)-\(Q(d_1, d_1)=\text{true}, Q(d_1, d_2)=\text{false}\)-\(P(d_1, d_1)=\text{false}, P(d_2, d_1)=\text{irrelevant}\)-\(\alpha\) is false \( I_2(\alpha)= F \)This breakdown aligns with the provided interpretations and demonstrates the differing truth values of \(\alpha\) under different interpretations.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

More Books

Students also viewed these Databases questions