The State X makes it a crime to take and carry away the property of another with the intent to permanently deprive him/her of said property.

Consider the following scenario:

Debra and Carol attended a social function a block away from their homes. The two wore similar coats to the event. After the event, Debra grabbed what she thought was her coat. She learned later that the coat she took belonged to Carol. Has Debra violated the State X criminal statute?

Question 7 options:

No, because Debra took the coat only one block away.

Yes, because Debra grabbed Carol's coat and took it home with her.

Yes, because Debra took Carol's coat.

No, because Debra was mistaken about the ownership of the coat and did not intend to deprive.