Question
This assignment is based on the case of trichloroethylene exposure in Woburn, MA. The case is the subject of an excellent book by Jonathan Harr
This assignment is based on the case of trichloroethylene exposure in Woburn, MA. The case is the subject of an excellent book by Jonathan Harr called A Civil Action, and a so-so movie of the same name.
Two of the wells in the town of Woburn were contaminated with trichloroethylene (TCE), an industrial solvent that I know some of you are familiar with in other contexts. Several of the children exposed to the water developed leukemia and sued the companies that operated facilities where the chemical was used. In this assignment, we will use Monte Carlo analysis to characterize the risk to the exposed children.
The three principal routes of exposure are:
Water ingestion
Inhalation of ambient air
Inhalation of TCE that evaporates from shower water
Use the data in the table below to respond to the following..
1. Calculate the average daily dose (ADD) and risk for each route of exposure based on average values.
2. Do a run with Crystal Ball (which is an free excel extension). Based on the results of the run, state the upper and lower 95% confidence limits for each of the risks. Determine the parameters that have the greatest influence on the results. Make sure you define the assumption for each uncertain parameter based on the data in the table prior to running Crystal Ball. .
3. Write a brief essay (no more than a page) explaining your results to a lay person.
Parameter | Average | Units | Distribution |
TCE concentration in water | 225 | ug/L | Uniform 183 - 267 ug/L |
Water intake | 0.87 | L/day | Normal Mean: 0.87 L/day 95th percentile: 2 L/day |
TCE concentration in ambient air | 0.86 | ug/m3 | Uniform 0.51 - 1.22 ug/m3 |
Breathing rate | 13.1 | m3/day | Normal Mean: 13.1 m3/day 95th percentile: 19.3 m3/day |
TCE concentration in room during a shower | 1033 | ug/m3 | Uniform 689 - 1378 ug/m3 |
Time per shower | 10 | minutes | Normal Mean: 10 minutes Std dev.: 5 minutes |
Body Weight | 52 | kg | Normal Mean: 52 kg Std dev.: 10 kg |
Exposure duration | 10 | years |
|
Average lifetime | 70 | years |
|
Cancer potency for inhalation | 5.88E-6 | kg-day/ug |
|
Cancer potency for ingestion | 4.6E-5 | kg-day/ug |
|
.Note that the EPA has withdrawn its cancer potency values from IRIS. I took the numbers in the table from other literature.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started