Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
To tackle Exercise 1 1 . 1 3 from your assignment, which focuses on comparing four different models of penguin body mass using Bayesian methods,
To tackle Exercise from your assignment, which focuses on comparing four different models of penguin body mass using Bayesian methods, we'll proceed stepbystep as outlined:
Exercise : Penguins! Comparing Models
a Simulate Models:
First, we need to simulate the four models based on the provided formulas:
Model : bodymassg ~ flipperlengthmm
Model : bodymassg ~ species
Model : bodymassg ~ flipperlengthmm species
Model : bodymassg ~ flipperlengthmm billlengthmm billdepthmm
b Produce and Compare Plots:
After simulating the models, we'll produce plots to visually compare them. These plots will likely include:
Explanation:
Scatter plots of observed vs predicted body mass.
Posterior distributions of parameters for each model.
Any other relevant diagnostic plots like residual plots if needed
c Use fold Crossvalidation:
We'll use fold crossvalidation to assess and compare the posterior predictive quality of the models. This involves:Implementing crossvalidation using predictionsummarycv or similar functions.
Explanation:Implementing crossvalidation using predictionsummarycv or similar functions.
Comparing metrics like mean squared error MSE root mean squared error RMSE or others as appropriate.
d Evaluate and Compare ELPD:
We will evaluate and compare the expected log predictive density ELPD to assess the predictive accuracy of each model. This step is crucial in Bayesian model comparison to understand which model performs better in predicting unseen data.
e Summary and Conclusion:
Finally, we'll summarize the findings and discuss which of the four models appears to be the "best" based on the evaluations in steps c and d
Detailed Approach
Explanation:
Simulate Models: Define each model using the specified formulas and simulate data based on these models. Ensure the simulation captures the essence of the relationships described eg linear relationships, speciesspecific effects
Produce and Compare Plots: Create plots to compare observed vs predicted body mass across the models. Also, visualize posterior distributions of model parameters to understand uncertainties and differences between models.
Crossvalidation: Implement fold crossvalidation to obtain metrics that quantify each model's predictive performance. This step ensures robust evaluation by simulating how each model generalizes to new data.
ELPD Comparison: Compute and compare ELPD values across models to determine which model provides the best balance between fit and complexity. Lower ELPD indicates better predictive performance.
Conclusion: Based on the results from crossvalidation and ELPD comparison, conclude which model is preferred and why. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of each model in light of the penguin body mass prediction task.
Submission Format
Your submission should include:
Explanation:
An HTML document containing:
All R code used for simulations, plots, crossvalidation, and ELPD calculations.
Explanations of each step, including interpretations of results.
Outputs such as plots and tables.
An Rmd file or extracted from the HTML with the same content, for reproducibility.
Ensure the document is wellorganized with appropriate headers and sections corresponding to each part of the exercise. References to relevant course materials or textbooks should support your interpretations and choices throughout the analysis.
By following this structured approach, you can systematically compare the models and provide a clear, wellsupported conclusion on which model is best suited for predicting penguin body mass based on the given data.
AS PER ABOVE SITUATION, WRITE THE CODE.
NEED CODE FOR
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started