Question
With reference to a specific piece of UK employment legislation, evaluate to what extent the precarious tourism and hospitality workforce (employees, workers, and self-employed) are
With reference to a specific piece of UK employment legislation, evaluate to what extent the precarious tourism and hospitality workforce (employees, workers, and self-employed) are protected by this legislation. Your evaluation should be based on relevant evidence and examples.
This essay looks at the labour issues facing the UK tourism and hospitality industry and how the Employment Rights Act of 1996 helps to protect workers. To evaluate how well the law protects people's rights, it makes use of HRM theories and frameworks. The essay also looks at leadership, organisational culture, organisational structures, and cultural and environmental factors in order to address the difficulties of managing people in various organisations, cultures, and environments. A thorough grasp of the regulatory framework controlling the precarious workforce in the sector is provided by an examination of the legal aspects of HRM and employment, including working hours, employment contracts, and dismissals.
Work arrangements that are characterised by a lack of benefits, insecurity, and instability are referred to as precarious employment. Within the UK tourism and hospitality industry, part-time, temporary, or zero-hour contracts are frequently employed, leading to uncertainty for the workforce.Employer and employee agree to work fewer hours than a full-time position under terms of part-time contracts, with the employee receiving employment benefits commensurate with the fewer hours worked. Temporary contracts, which are frequently used for short-term staffing needs, specify a predetermined period of employment. Employers under zero-hour contracts are not required to provide a minimum number of hours, and workers are essentially "on call." While zero-hour contracts do not ensure regular work or specific benefits, part-time contracts do offer stability, predictable schedules, fixed duration, guaranteed hours, and flexibility.
In order to maximise performance and accomplish organisational objectives, HRM entails the strategic management of an organization's workforce. A significant piece of UK law governing the rights of workers, employees, and, to some extent, independent contractors is the Employment Rights Act of 1996. It lists a number of employment rights, including the right to written job details, defence against wrongful termination, and rights regarding redundancy(Gov. et al.).
Temporary and seasonal employment are common in the tourism and hospitality industries, which can result in inconsistent income and job insecurity.Seasonal employment refers to a work arrangement in which individuals are engaged in their work during particular periods of the year, which align with fluctuations in seasonal demand within a particular industry. Holidays and tourist seasons are examples of seasonal peaks that influence short-term contracts. Zero-hours contracts give flexibility, but they also give workers no certainty over their pay and working hours. Flexible and part-time work schedules are typical, but they can also lead to instability. Employees frequently work in gig economies in roles like freelancing or on-demand labour, which might not come with the same benefits and protections as traditional employment.
There are differences in rights and benefits because the workforce is made up of a diverse mix of workers, employees, and independent contractors with varying legal statuses and entitlements. Many employees rely significantly on tips and service fees, which can lead to unstable income and increased susceptibility to client behaviour. Insufficient instructionInsufficient opportunities for career development and training, especially for entry-level or temporary jobs, may impede career advancement within the industry.
Different employment statuses, each with its own set of rights, responsibilities, and job security, define the tourism and hospitality (T&H) workforce. Employees are people who are employed under a contract that provides more stability and benefits like paid time off, sick pay, and pension contributions. They also work regular hours and have a fixed salary. They frequently work in positions within the industry that call for specialised knowledge or duties.
Workers are people who are hired under contract to complete tasks or provide services, but they might not fit the requirements for full employee status. Although their arrangement is more flexible, they still have some fundamental employment rights. Their work may be seasonal or sporadic, and their hours may be erratic or informal. They are entitled to benefits like holiday pay, the federal minimum wage, and defence against unauthorised deductions.
People who operate their own businesses or provide services to clients as independent contractors are known as self-employed people. They are in charge of their own taxes and National Insurance contributions, and they have more control over their work. They usually work on a project or task basis, offering clients in the T&H sector specialised services.
The distinctions between worker, employee, and self-employed statuses create intersections and challenges that can result in legal disputes and difficulties identifying the proper employment classification. Because the T&H sector is inherently unstable due to its reliance on seasonal peaks and fluctuating demand, a combination of these employment statuses are frequently found in the workforce.
The Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA 1996) safeguards both employers and employees against wrongful termination, rights to redundancy, regulations on working hours, and entitlements to leave. It is especially crucial for the UK's tourism and hospitality industry, which deals with a changing and frequently unstable job market. The Act requires employers to follow reasonable and open procedures when terminating employees, giving them a chance to react and file an appeal. Additionally, it contains provisions for part-timers, including pro rata benefits, equitable treatment in training and career development, and facility access.
Due to its primary focus on traditional employer-employee relationships, the ERA 1996 offers limited protections for self-employed individuals. Their rights to certain employment benefits, protection from unjust dismissal, and rights in the event of a redundancy are thus diminished. The gig economy, which challenges conventional ideas of employment relationships, is one example of how work arrangements are changing and may not be fully covered by the Act.
In the tourism and hospitality industry, self-employed people have limited protection under the Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA 1996). The Act gives self-employed people fewer statutory protections because it primarily concentrates on the rights and protections of employees and workers. The Act recognises self-employed people's autonomy but offers little recourse in conflict resolution.
Considerations for possible amendments should be made in order to address these issues, with a focus on protecting independent contractors and workers. Changes should be made to address issues unique to the industry, like the rights of seasonal workers and the cyclical nature of employment. The need of industry awareness and ERA 1996 compliance should be emphasised, with a focus on educating employers and employees about the intricacies of the law. The T&H sector should actively support education and training programmes to guarantee that all parties involved are aware of their rights and responsibilities with regard to employment under the ERA 1996.
Although the Employment Rights Act of 1996 offers certain safeguards, its efficacy in protecting the precarious labour force in the tourism and hospitality sectors is questionable. For example, even though exclusivity clauses in zero-hours contracts are prohibited by the Act (Legislation.gov.uk, 2024), these contracts nonetheless constitute a type of precarious employment that is typical in the sector. Furthermore, the Act's protections predominantly apply to 'employees', potentially leaving 'workers' and the 'self-employed' with fewer legal safeguards.
An employee of a hotel challenged their termination during the off-peak season by filing a claim under the ERA 1996. According to the case analysis, the employee successfully argued that the dismissal lacked justification and that fair procedures were followed, which resulted in the employment tribunal ordering the employee's reinstatement or payment (Smith v. Hotel Group, 2019).
The UK's travel and hospitality (T&H) industry faces particular difficulties, such as irregular work schedules, seasonal employment, short-term contracts, low job security, and difficult working conditions. The Employment Relations Act (ERA) of 1996 offers redundancy rights, benefits, and safeguards against unjust dismissal. Applying the Act to the diverse T&H workforce, in particular part-time, seasonal, and independent contractors, presents difficulties, though.
It is debatable whether the Act is effective in resolving these issues, especially when it comes to self-employed people, part-time and zero-hour contracts, and terminations that occur during busy times of the year. Legislative changes, industry cooperation, education and awareness campaigns, policy innovation, and new methods of worker protectionwhich take into account the gig economy, part-time employment, and seasonal fluctuationsshould all be taken into account in the future developments of employment laws.This would guarantee everyone in the T&H industry a safe and equitable workplace.
Does the essay answer the question?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started