With this ratio information, reflect the answers not in ratios $(\%)$ but in numbers $($$$)$ and with the second table do a vertical and a horizontal analysis:

$2024-2023-2022$

Cash$-$ year end $$245,000-$ $$324,000-$ $$321,000$

Operating expenses$-$ annual $1,150,000-1,220,000-1,200,000$

Accounts payable$-$ year end $42,000-48,000-41,000$

Sales revenues$-$ annual $1,620,000-1,650,000-1,600,000$

Accounts receivable$-$ year end $53,000-40,000-44,000$