Question
Yarra Glen Orchard ('YGO') is located just outside Yarra Glen in Victoria. The orchard grows three types of apples, oranges and pears, and it supplies
Yarra Glen Orchard ('YGO') is located just outside Yarra Glen in Victoria. The orchard grows three types of apples, oranges and pears, and it supplies fresh food retailers across Melbourne. In the past, YGO had relied heavily on labour from backpackers and young workers travelling in Australia to pick fruit but due to the border restrictions in place over the last three years and the low unemployment rate in Australia, it has been difficult to find workers. YGO often doesn't have enough workers to pick all the fruit and it has had to cancel some supply contracts because it can't fulfil them.
Things are starting to pick up when the Victorian government announces that Thursday 22 September 2022 will be a one-off public holiday in commemoration of the death of Queen Elizabeth II. This is problematic for YGO because it can't close for the day because the fruit needs to be picked to meet orders that weekend. 20 part-time employees engaged under ongoing contracts of employment as fruit pickers ordinarily work on Thursdays.
On 16 September 2022, upon learning about the public holiday, William, the HR Manager of YGO, consults YGO's enterprise agreement. Clause 12 states:
12 Public Holidays
12.1 The following days are Public Holidays: New Year's Day, Australia Day, Good Friday, Easter Saturday, Easter Monday, Anzac Day, Queen's Birthday, Christmas Day and Boxing Day or any other one-off Public Holidays as announced by the Victorian or Commonwealth governments.
12.2 Employees rostered to work on public holidays will be paid at their ordinary rate of pay plus a 25% loading per hour.
William realises that clause 12 applies to the 20 part-time fruit pickers.
Later that day, William calls a meeting with Harry and Meghan, who own YGO, and Kate, YGO's accountant. After considering the cost of operating on 22 September, the four of them agree that the best thing to do is to pay the 20 employees who ordinarily work on Thursdays their ordinary hourly wages for the day and direct them to perform work as usual. They agree to give each worker a crate of fruit to thank them for working that day.
Via email, William explains this to the 20 employees. He notes that YGO has only recently begun to recover from "hard times" and thanks the employees for their loyalty. He writes that YGO's owners recognise that each of them will be "doing the company a big favour" by working on 22 September and they are very grateful to them.
You work for the Fruit Pickers Union. Soon after William sends the email, you receive a call from Edward, one of your members who works at YGO. Edward asks you what, if anything, he and the other workers at YGO can do in response to William's email.
"We're so sick of how poorly they treat us," Edward says. "Our wages are low and now this! The orchard can't operate without our hard work. Can't we just go on strike?"
Advise Edward.
Use real cases and rules as references. Use the IRAC method to answer the question (issue, rule, application, conclusion).
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started