You have embarked on an ambitious research project: to create life in a test tube. You boil up a rich mixture of yeast extract and amino acids in a flask, along with a sprinkling of the inorganic salts known to be essential for life. You seal the flask and allow it to cool. After several months, the liquid is as clear as ever, and there are no signs of life. A friend suggests that excluding the air was a mistake, since most life as we know it requires oxygen. You repeat the experiment, but this time you leave the flask open to the atmosphere. To your great delight, the liquid becomes cloudy after a few days, and, under the microscope, you see beautiful small cells that are clearly growing and dividing. Does this experiment prove that you managed to generate a novel lifeform? How might you redesign your experiment to allow air into the flask, yet eliminate the possibility that contamination by airborne microorganisms is the explanation for the results?