2.36. Crosson (1994, p. 168) described an analysis of published medical studies involving treatments for heart attacks.
Question:
2.36. Crosson (1994, p. 168) described an analysis of published medical studies involving treatments for heart attacks. In the studies having randomization and strong controls for bias, the new therapy provided improved treatment 9% of the time. In studies without randomization or other controlsfor bias, the new therapy provided improved treatment 58% of the time. Select the correct response(s).
(a) This result suggests it is better not to use randomization in medical studies, because it is harder to show that new ideas arc beneficial.
(b) Many newspaper articles that suggest that a particular food, drug, or environmental agent is harmful or beneficial should be viewed skeptically, unless we learn more about the statistical design and analysis for the study.
(c) This result suggests that you should be skeptical about published results of medical studies that are not randomized, controlled studies.
(d) Controlling for biases, both suspected and unsuspected, is necessary in medical research but not in social research, because the social sciences deal in subjective rather than objective truth.
Step by Step Answer:
Statistical Methods For The Social Sciences
ISBN: 9781292021669
4th Edition
Authors: Barbara Finlay, Alan Agresti