1: One night, Tammy decided to go out dancing with her friend Mary. She picked Mary up from her house, and they drove to Dave's Disco, where they proceeded to drink alcoholic cocktails and dance. At about 2am, after the effects of the alcohol had worn off, T and M decided to head home. Tammy dropped M off, and proceeded to her grandparent's home. She arrived at 2:30am. Arturo was waiting up for her. He was furious, accused her of drinking based on her the alcohol he smelled on her breath, and told T that she acted "dangerously and irresponsibly." he grounded her for one week. 1. What is the rule from this case? 13

Scenario (Precedent) 2: Another night when T felt like socializing with a bunch of her high school friends, she decided to go to a a high school party she had heard about. Around 10pm, she walked by herself about a half a mile through the suburb she lives in until she arrived at the home of Theo, was was hosting a keg party at his parents' house while his parents were away. T drank beer, got to visit with many different groups of her friends, and was home by 1am. Arturo and Elizabeth heard her come in because it woke them up. They told her they had heard about the party and that she was grounded for the following night. 2. What is the Rule from Precedent 2? Scenario (Precedent) 3: T loves spending time outdoors with her orchestra friends, so she was happy to be invited to a dinner picnic at a nearby waterfall and lake. She loved this group of friends, and the lake environment was peaceful and beautiful. Since there would be park rangers working in the evening, T and her friends decided not to bring alcohol to their picnic. Instead, they grilled food, roasted marshmallows, and sang camp songs. T lost track of the time and came home late, around 1am. When E and A heard her come home and asked her if she had been drinking, she said no. T did not get in trouble and did not get grounded. 3. What is the Rule from Precedent 3?