Question
1. X sold to Y real estate for a stipulated price. The agreement was oral. X has not yet delivered the real estate. Y has
1. X sold to Y real estate for a stipulated price. The agreement was oral. X has not yet
delivered the real estate. Y has not yet paid the price. Y offered to buy, but X refused to
go ahead with the agreement. Under the Satute of Frauds, to be enforceable, an
agreement for the sale of real estate must be in writing (Art 1403 [2e]); Y sued for
specific performance. Xs attorney objected, setting up the Statute of Frauds as the reason
for the objection.
a. May the contract be proved by the oral evidence?
b. Suppose in the above problem, the price had already been paid, would your answer be
the same?
2. X and Y, neighbors, orally agreed that X would sell and Y would buy Xs transistor radio
for 200 three years from the date of agreement. At the end of three years, X refused to
hand over the radio although Y was willing to pay. Is the agreement enforceable unde the
Statute of Frauds?
3. X and Y, neighbors, orally agreed that from that day, Y would not erect a garage on his
property till after three years. A week later, Y began to erect the garage in violation of
the agreement. X complains and Y sets up the Statute of Frauds. Decide
4. A servant had an oral contract which allowed him P100 a month salary. He served
continuously for twelve years. Master refused payment on the ground that the contract
having lasted for more that 1 year, the same should have been in writing to be
enforceable. Is the servant entitled to pay?
5. X and Y orally agreed in 2006 to marry each other in 2010. When 2010 came, X refused
to marry Y, who now seeks damages. Would Y be allowed to prove the oral agreement?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started