Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
6. CHALLENGE. Peirce's Law and Curry's Paradox We start with a simple identity due to philosopher CHARLES PEIRCE (18391914). An odd consequence is Curry's paradox,
6. CHALLENGE. Peirce's Law and Curry's Paradox We start with a simple identity due to philosopher CHARLES PEIRCE (18391914). An odd consequence is Curry's paradox, discovered by logician HASKELL CURRY (19001982). Like Russell's paradox (discussed in lectures), the paradox arises when we allow self-reference. (a) Show that Peirce's law, ((p = q) = p =p is a tautology via truth tables. (b) Suppose that (p = q) Apis true. Use part (a) and modus ponens to deduce q. (c) Argue informally that, for any proposition q, the self-referential sentence p= If p is true, then it implies q satisfies (p = 9) Ap. (d) Combine (b) and (c) to conclude that anything is true. What has gone wrong here? 6. CHALLENGE. Peirce's Law and Curry's Paradox We start with a simple identity due to philosopher CHARLES PEIRCE (18391914). An odd consequence is Curry's paradox, discovered by logician HASKELL CURRY (19001982). Like Russell's paradox (discussed in lectures), the paradox arises when we allow self-reference. (a) Show that Peirce's law, ((p = q) = p =p is a tautology via truth tables. (b) Suppose that (p = q) Apis true. Use part (a) and modus ponens to deduce q. (c) Argue informally that, for any proposition q, the self-referential sentence p= If p is true, then it implies q satisfies (p = 9) Ap. (d) Combine (b) and (c) to conclude that anything is true. What has gone wrong here
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started