Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

A Mississippi chicken processing plant fired most of its remaining workers after nearly 100 accused of immigration violations were arrested last week, witnesses said, an

A Mississippi chicken processing plant fired most of its remaining workers after nearly 100 accused of immigration violations were arrested last week, witnesses said, an indication that the crackdown could make finding work in the state's poultry industry more difficult for Latino immigrants.

Terry Truett, a volunteer with the Mississippi Immigration Coalition, said she and others were called Tuesday to a Morton Park where former PH Food workers were staging a protest, saying the company had abruptly fired them at the end of their shift and was illegally withholding pay.

It's unclear exactly how many were fired, although Truett said more than 100 workers' names were collected at the protest in Morton, about 40 miles (65 kilometers) east of Jackson.

PH Food is one of seven Mississippi plants raided Aug. 7 by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. The agencyarrested 680 people accused of working in the United States without legal permission, quickly releasing about 300. ICE also seized company documents as part of an investigation into what managers knew. ICE said it arrested 99 people at PH Food.

Normally, when a company with more than 100 employees lays off more than a third of its workforce, it must give 60 days' notice to affected employees, and local and state government. Dianne Bell, a spokeswoman for the Mississippi Department of Security, said PH Foods has not filed notice with the state. Bell said a company employee told her Wednesday that there had been no layoffs.

The company told The Associated Press on Wednesday to call back and later hung up on a reporter. On Thursday, a person who answered the phone said the company isn't commenting. Phone calls to the payroll company weren't returned.

Truett and others say most of the people ICE arrested at PH Food worked on the first shift. Second-shift workers trickled back to work in the days after the raid even though most lack legal status, according to the Rev. Roberto Mena, pastor of St. Martin de Porres Catholic Church.

"Some almost all of them they are undocumented in some way," Mena said.

Truett and Mena said workers came to the church after the Tuesday protest to consult with lawyers. Others held a meeting at a nearby restaurant because the church was too small for the crowd.

Asearch warrant unsealed last week cites aconfidential informant telling investigators that workers at PH Food knew most of its 240 workers didn't have legal permission to work in the United States. The informant told investigators that managers encouraged workers to make up Social Security numbers and tried to use a payroll outsourcing firm in Louisiana to mask their activities.

The informant also alleged that PH and the payroll company didn't try to verify the authenticity of work documents, even though Mississippi state law requires employers to check documents using E-Verify, an otherwise voluntary online federal system. At other plants that were raided, investigators presented efforts that employees were working under assumed but real identities often bought on the black market.

No PH Food managers have been charged, although U.S. Attorney Mike Hurst has said a criminal investigation continues.

PH and another plant raided in nearby Pelahatchie A&B Inc. are identified in sworn statements as being owned by California resident Huo You Liang, known to his Mississippi employees as Victor Liang.

Truett said workers were asked to sign I-9 forms verifying their identities after the raid. American workers usually sign such forms as they begin employment. Then managers came through the plant Tuesday and fired all but "a handful" of workers on the spot, she said.

Karla Vazquez-Elmore, who works for an immigration law firm in Jackson, said at least four of her firm's clients who weren't arrested last week have contacted her to say they were fired by PH Food. She said one client among those arrested last week told her PH Foods denied the worker's final paycheck.

Mena, like Vazquez-Elmore and Truett, said at least some workers who were arrested last week had gone to PH Food seeking their paycheck but were denied. That's against federal law, even if people don't have legal permission to work.

Truett said desperation led people to protest, even though many Latinos in chicken plant towns are in near seclusion right now for fear of arrest.

"They were at wit's end," Truett said. "They felt like they had nothing to lose. These folks have no income."

Questions

  1. How many moral issues that are raised by this case can you identify, and explain them in detail?
  2. How would an act utilitarian respond to each of these moral issues?
  3. How would a rule utilitarian respond to each of these moral issues?
  4. How would a Kantian, by applying the first formulation of the categorical imperative, respond to each of these moral issues?
  5. How would a Kantian, by applying the second formulation of the categorical imperative, respond to each of these moral issues?
  6. What is your response to each of these moral issues (if you would respond based on a different moral standard than any of those identified in the preceding four questions)?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

Moral Issues 1 PH Foods sudden and mass firing of workers without giving them 60 days notice is a moral issue This violates the workers rights to due process and security in their employment 2 The com... blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Management A Practical Introduction

Authors: Angelo Kinicki, Brian Williams

5th edition

978-1111821227, 9781133190363, 1111821224, 1133190367, 978-0078112713

More Books

Students also viewed these General Management questions

Question

LO.3 Discuss the tax consequences of qualified plans.

Answered: 1 week ago