Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Alec was an actor and producer in a small, independent film. He had a scene coming up where he had to shoot an actor, Miranda.

Alec was an actor and producer in a small, independent film. He had a scene coming up where he had to shoot an actor, Miranda. He organised a professional shooter to come to the film set to give him and other cast members a lesson in shooting. They practiced shooting targets with live ammunition. Alec pulled out some of the props and put them next to the real weapons. The prop weapons looked very realistic and it was difficult to tell them apart. The practice stopped for lunch.

During lunch, Alec grabbed a weapon from the table and went to Miranda's caravan to rehearse the scene. He mainly wanted to work on her reactions to being shot. They practiced fighting over the gun for the scene and Alec pulled the trigger. He had not realised that he had grabbed a real gun instead of a prop. He shot Miranda on her right shoulder.

Alec felt whoozy at the sight of blood and panicked. He ran to his caravan and shut the door. He practiced his breathing exercises to calm down. He then called his agent in a panic.

Alec said, 'Oh my god. I think I killed her. I shot her. It was a real gun. There were real bullets. Oh god, oh god.'

The agent tried to calm Alec down and get more details. It took a while for the agent to realise that Alec had left Miranda injured and alone. The agent promised to look after it all. Alec assumed that this meant that the agent would call for help. Alec took a Valium and passed out on his couch.

In fact, the agent did not call for help. The agent was distracted by a really famous person calling for attention and forgot all about it.

Alec woke up three hours later when the camera person, Coco, banged on his caravan door warning that they were about to start filming.

Alec said, 'Oh. Is filming going ahead? Does that mean Miranda is okay? Oh what a relief.' When Coco said that she didn't know what Alec was talking about, Alec panicked. He ran to Miranda's caravan. Miranda was lying in a pool of blood. Alec was afraid to touch her and almost passed out because of the blood. Coco saw the blood and called for an ambulance. She then drew on some first aid training and put pressure on the wound to stop the bleeding.

An ambulance arrived 50 minutes later. Miranda died on the way to the hospital. There was evidence that if medical treatment had been provided earlier she would not have died.

under legislation (NSW)

problem question: Discuss Alec's liability for homicide.

must be answered in the following structure:

1. Offender 1

1.1. Introduction

Address: Charges, defences, burdens and standards of proof

1.2. Crime 1 (. 'Murder')

1.2.1. Actus reus/conduct elements

1.2.2. Mens rea/fault elements

1.2.3. Temporal coincidence (actus reus/mens rea at the same time)

1.2.4. Conclusion for Crime 1

1.3. Crime 2 ( involuntary manslaughter)

If there is another offence that the defendant could be charged with (either in addition to, or in the alternative to, Crime 1), address each element of the offence taking similar steps to those outlined for Crime 1.

1.4. Defence / Partial Defence 1

1.4.1. Burden and standard of proof (if haven't already done so in introduction)

1.4.2. Address each element in turn

1.4.3. Conclusion for Defence 1

1.5. Defence / Partial Defence 2

If there is another defence that the defendant could raise, repeat the steps outlined for Defence 1.

1.6 Overall Conclusion

for crime 2 could you discuss about involuntary manslaughter.

thoroughly answered please. and if there is causation "The prosecution must prove factual and legal causation and intervene in order to satisfy the accused cause of the death of victim r v royal." please explain how to applies to it. Dont forget to follow the structure above to answer please.

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Microeconomics An Intuitive Approach with Calculus

Authors: Thomas Nechyba

1st edition

978-0538453257

Students also viewed these Law questions