Question
Anna, a resident of Kentucky, sells hand blown-glass figurines. Anna primarily sells her glassware at local festivals and craft-shows in Kentucky, Indiana, & Ohio. To
Anna, a resident of Kentucky, sells hand blown-glass figurines. Anna primarily sells her glassware at local festivals and craft-shows in Kentucky, Indiana, & Ohio. To supplement her in-person sales, Anna also runs an Etsy shop online. The vast majority of Annas sells on Etsy are to residents of the three (3) states listed above. She has never made a sale to anyone in Alaska, California, Florida, Hawaii, or Vermont. While at a craft show in Ohio, Anna sells a large glass figurine to Becky, who lives in Ohio. While gently, and with all care and due diligence, carrying the figurine to her car, the glass figurine shatters in Beckys hands due to Annas manufacturing defect. The shattered glass cuts Beckys arms, chest, and face, and pieces of glass gets lodged in Beckys eye. Becky is significantly harmed by the glass from the shattered figurine. Beckys mother, Carla, who lives in Florida, sees pictures of Beckys injuries on Facebook and experiences extreme emotional distress from seeing her daughter so badly hurt. Carla looks at Annas Etsy page and sees that Anna advertises to everyone in the United States and is willing to sell to anyone in the United States via an online order form. Carla does not order anything from Annas Etsy page. Using the above stated information, answer the following questions:
A: Becky wants to file a lawsuit against Anna in Ohio state court for damages due to the injuries she sustained from the shattered glass figurine. Discuss whether or not Ohio can exercise jurisdiction, both subject matter and personal, over Anna for this matter.
B. After Becky files her lawsuit in Ohio state court against Anna, Anna wants the matter to be heard in federal court, not Ohio state court. Discuss whether or not Anna will be successful in having the lawsuit removed to federal court. What would Anna have to show to have the case removed to federal court?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started