At Samir's hearing, the Minister's Counsel made his oral closing submissions. In his oral closing submissions, he summarized the exact same pointsmade by the visa officer in the refusal letter and did not add any new information.

However, there was no time for you to make oral submissions or closing statements. As a result, the Board Member has asked that you submitwritten submissions for Samir.

please provide a formal submission letter with the closing points for Samir. Please verify the spelling and grammar of your submission. Please ensure you cite relevant sections and subsections of the IRPA, IRPR,and Case Law in your submissions. Please donot cite case law that has been previouslymentioned in the course material - you should be conducting your own research onrelevant caselaw. When citing relevant case law please ensure the following:

- a copy of the actual case law, or a link to the URL where the case law you have cited is available to review

- include in your submission an explanation of how your citedcase law is relevant toSamir and Yasmine'scase