Bus Case 1: Holding Fast by John T. Gourville Your paper should be written in the first person as the CEO of this company. When responding to the following questions, apply relevant management terms and concepts learned so far in this course: What are all the issues/considerations surrounding the decision regarding resorbables? Be specific! Create a bulleted list them in order of their importance! (Hint: There are many issues to consider!) Given the situation, should Crescordia launch resorbables? o If so, in what manner and with what guidelines? Be specific in detailing all elements! If not, what will your approach be for this market? Be specific in detailing all elements! o Hint: Im expecting you to demonstrate how your approach will address/manage the many issues you have identified. Create a formatted list of pros and cons of your decision. Include how your decision will affect your current business model and future business prospects. What key learnings did you take from analyzing this case?

HBR CASE STuby, Holding fiast different and it wasn't possible to replicate every individual's physiology in the lab. The Governing Body A week later, as Walsh approacined the boardroom door for the executive committee meeting, the atmosphere seemed charged. Everyone had a strong opinion on the main topic the committee would be discussing today. probably most excited to see resorb. ables back on the agenda was jane LaMott, vice president of sales. Walsh noted how antsy she seemed during Miskimen's RRI) update and, as som "Can't do it," Rob Bond piped up. s chief operating officer, he was acutely aware of the complexity of a new platform launch. "If" we enter the market at all, we'll need to do it with the full set of implants plates and screws in all relcvant sizes - plus the hand and power tools to attach these implants." He nodded in LaMoll's direction. "And you'll need an education offering to support them. And none of it has a chance of profitability if we can't scale production." That sent the group into a discussion of the retoding and inventory levels required, whiclr quickly devolved into side debates. "If there is one thing surgeons hate to do, it's to go back in on a kid to remove an implant. They get no credit if it goes right and a huge headache if it goes wrong." as Miskimen finished, gave her the nod to lead off the discussion. "In the past few months, three of our top-tier accounts have placed substantial orders with Innostat," she said omi nously. "And here's the kicker: They weren't just for resorbables. They inclucled metal devices directly equivalent to ones that we sell." She went on to offer her analysis. These were surgeons who were doing some experinentation with resorbables, which they couldn't procure from Crescordia. "And once they turned to Innostat for resorbables-well, the camel's nose was under the tent." Walsh leaned forward in his chair. "That's an important point, fane. Hav. ing a resorbables option, even if limited, might prevent market share erosion in other areas." Chief marketer Diane Robinson took her cue. "I couldn't disagre more," she said. "Our market share is a function of our reputation for quality. If we put out a product that isn't tep to our standards, will people trust us with the rest of the product line?" She gave LaMont a conciliatory look. "Perhaps if we could move into this new technology in a very lim. ited way - " "One conversation, folks," Walsh reminded them, then noticed that Miski men was waiting patiently for the floor. He invited him to speak his mind. "What about targeting just the pediatric market for a start?" Miskimen suggested. "It's a smaller range of sizes, and, from my perspective, it offers the grealest potential berefit to doctors and paticnts." LaMott looked at Miskimen yrate. fully. "Not to mention the biggest source of demand," she said. "If there is one thitig sugeons hate to (o), it's to go back in on a kid to remove an implant. "They get nocredit if it goes right and a huge headache if it goes wrong. That's a territic icteas." Up to this point, legal counsel Sam Maddox had hung back, observing the back-and-forth with alr air of detach. ment. Now he made a face as though he wcre smelling sulfur. "Let me get this straight," lese drawled. "We have a product that is probably substandard. We're expecting it to get better based on what we learn in the field. And our human guinea pigs are...children? Sounds like a field day for tort lawyers. Carrt we try it out on old people or something?" He frowned thoughttully. "Then again, I'm not sure I want my mother suing as, cither." What's In It for Us? Walsh was glad he'd put the item on the agenda, even though the discussion was far from conclusive. The group tabled the resorbables debate until the next meeting, with various people promising to scare up relevant data. The next day, however, Walsh had a morning of work scheduled with CFO Calvin Westbrosk, and it struck him that Westbook hadn't weighed in. "I don't know, Peter," Westbrook admitted. "I'm no expert, but at this point I question the whole resorbables idea. Scientists have been promising us re" sults for 20 years, and what do we have to show for it? It reminds me of that joke about 13razil: It's the country of the luture-and always will be." Walsh smiled. "But I think we're getting close. What if the market does ma" terialize? It will be very fertile for whoever gets it right. I want Crescordia to be the one to make that happen." "Well, there again, l'm not so sure," Westbrook said. "I was thinking about this last night. leet's assume the very best scenario-- that we are the ones to get it right. Our resorbable implants succeed in the fiedd and become the product of choice. Then, everyone responds and we see a gradual shift to the now technology. As I see it, we may be no better off." "How's that?" Walsh asked. "The margins will be only slightly better. But the retooling needed to make resorbables will be a huge capital expense." He sat for a few moments silently, letting Walsh ponder the point. Walsh ratsed his head finally and stared at his colleague intently. "I set what you're saying," he said. "With the lest of the industry making no headway, why be in a hury?" "Exactly," said Westbrook. "Why usher out a golden era?" Should Crescordia launch a resorbables offering? - rour commentators offer expert advice beginaing on pate no. 38 IFARVARD BUSINESS RIVIRW Hoding 1, th the CASE STUDY mon procedure in pediatrics. In patients of all ages, old plates and screws could sometimes shift or come loose, causing painful protrusions. Just enough of the current generation of resorbables worked, it seemed, to keep Innostat in business and everyone else in the industry continuing their research. Even Walsh had to admit that, were he a surgeon, he might occasionally take the risk of using a resorbable. But Walsh wasn't a surgeon. He was the CEO of a company whose products were respected throughout the industry. Thanks to decades of refusing to compromise on quality, there were orthopedic surgeons out there who used nothing but Crescordia hardware. The company simply could not afford to do something and not do it right. Under Stress Walsh arrived at his office the next moming to a typical flurry of meetings, conference calls, and paperwork. It was ten o'clock before he found a chance to pop down to see Gary Miskimen, his head of R\&D. Miskimen was in the testing lab at the moment, his assistant told Walsh. She offered to page him. "No, no," Walsh said. "I'm heading that way anyway." Soon after, he found Miskimen and one of his managers, both in pristine lab coats, looking on as a technician operated one of the company's servohydraulic fatigue testing machines. The technician clamped a long, slender, metal screw into place, picked up her strain gauge and started the test. Miskimen filled Walsh in, murmuring, "The new cannulated screw versus the standard cortex screw." They stood staring, scarcely breathing, as the ten" sion built and built more. Finatly, the screw snapped. Miskimen's eyebrows rose. "Not bad," he said. The technician grinned. Miskimen turned to Walsh and gave him a proper greeting. "And what brings you down to the lab on this fine day?" "Actually, I was just curious to know if there was any news on the resorbables front," Walsh answered. "I know we're not due for a status update, but the subject came up yesterday." Miskimen looked to the manager be. side him. "We just finished some trials on the latest prototypes, didn't we?" The manager hurried off to get the data. "Don't get your hopes up," Miskimen said, as he and Walsh followed at a more measured pace. "It's not perfection." They walked along in silence for a few moments. Then Walsh spoke up. "I think it may be time to step up out efforts. Let's say we delay those new compression plates and put Wilkins on the case and maybe Sid Stratton..." Walsh glanced at Miskimen for a reaction. Miskimen rubbed his close-cropyed beard, then shook his head. "Peter, the truth is we've done as much as we can with resorbables in the lab. I know you don't want to beall this, bett we're not going to know what we need to know to make the product betler until we get it out in the refd. We need to get it into the surgeons' hands." "And into the patients" buties," Walsh said with a sigh. Miskincen was riglt; it wasn't what Walsh wanted to hear. But Walsh knew enough alorth the science to know Miskimen waslit just making excuses. Metal plates were relatively straightforwad folcst. They were inent, monciactive with body tissin', so what you saw in the lab was what you'd get in the heman body. The whole point of resorbables, on the other hand, was to be: reactive -10 interact with the hody and dissolve over time. But every body was JUNE 2005 37 HBR CASE STUDY. Halding fast to the cafeteria, one of the surgeons launched into an account of a difficult case he'd seen that week. "Get this: The guy's a conductor - you know, with a symphony orchestra--so he really needs that wrist action." The surgeon flicked an imaginary baton upward by way of illustration. "So, of course, what does he manage to break his very first time on Rollerblades?" Walsh winced in sympathy. "On top of that, it's the same wrist he fractured five years ago, falling off his podium - and it was fixed that time with a distal radius plate." The rest of the group made sympathetic noises; no one liked having to remove old plates to implant new ones. "But wait - it gets worse. He's from Europe, just came here last year. And his surgeon must have fan. cied himself on the leading edge, because that plate was resorbable. Or, shall we say, it was supposed to be." Now a great groan went up from the group, to the clear satisfaction of the surgeon. Everyone had a mental image of what he must have encountered, and it "let me guess," another doctor chimed in. "It looked like the hull of the Titanic in there." He sighed and shook his head. "And who knows if the resorbables on the market today are any better?" Walsh stiffened slightly and cleared his throat, anticipating what would come next. Sure enough, someone posed the question right away. "So, when is Crescordia going to make a resorbable fixation system? You guys would do it right. Finally, l'd have the confidence to use the darn things on a regular basis." Everyone looked at Walsh, but his response was as noncommittal as ever. "I wish we could give it to you today. But believe me, the science just isn't there yet. There's a reason those products are so buggy. And we wouldn't waste your time selling them to you. Out reputation-and yours-means too much to us." Walsh then adroitly shifted the topic to what Crescordia would introduce next, and the conversation moved on. He relaxed again when they arrived at the bustling cafeteria and he could play "Believe me, there's a reason those products are so buggy. And we wouldn't waste your time selling them to you. Our reputation-and yours-means too much to us." wasn't pretty. The idea behind resorb. able hardware was a good one. Like dissolving sutures, resorbable plates and screws were made of biodegradable polymers that held up long enough to do thcir job-to support a healing bonethen gradually disintegrated harmlessly into the patient's body. The first and second generations of the technology were far from perfect, though, as the surgcon's case and many like it made clear. After five years, there should have been nothing left of the plate in the conductor's wrist - the key words being "should have." host, offering pointers on what the various stations had to offer. As the trainees reconvened at the dining tables, Walsh sized up his seating options. Taking care not to spill his soup, he squeezed past a table with a group debating World Series prospects and joined a couple of surgeons who were obviously talking shop. One of them was asing his turkey rollup to describe a femur fracture he'd recently fixed. "So right here's where the blade plate had to go in," he was saying as he pressed a plastic knife through the pita. The fellow beside him interrupted. "And we're in a lateral position, right?" John T. Gourville (jgourville@hbs.edu) is an associate professur of marketing at Harvard Business School in Bostom and a coauthor, with John A. Quelch and V. Kasturi Rangan, of Problems and Cases in Health Care Marketing (McGraw-I/lil//hwin, 2005). I/is last article for HBR was "Pricing and the Psychology of Consumption," coauthored with Dilip Soman (September 2002). "Yeah, yeah. Need to get the posterior exposure for this one." The surgeon guided the blunt plastic point expertly past a layer of Havarti and ficked at some shredded lettuce. "And the question is, Are these fragments here going to take to lag-screw fixation? Because, if so, that'll save me a lot of work." He studied his subject intently for a moment, then shoved it into his mouth. Walsh laughed. "So much for that case!" he said. He wished he could eat with these guys every day. Fixated on Quality Later, in his office, Walsh returned to the challenge of resorbables. There was no question they would be great if they were reliable - and indeed Crescordia, along with many of its competitors, had been working on that problem for years. But were they ready for prime time? During internal trials, they still tended to fail about 8% of the time--sometimes disintegrating before the bone had fully healed and sometimes not fully disinte. grating at all. Not exactly Six Sigma. Unfortunately, not every company was so fussy. Walsh remembered lhe day back in the 1990s when he was stunned to find out that Innostat, an upstart competitor, was ready to launch a line of resorbable plates and screws. Walsh was confident he had the best scientists and R&D facilities in the business; could some geniuses have beaten them to the punch? Soon enough, the truth became clear, though it was only a partial relief: 'lhe product was even worse than what Crescordia could have put on the market at the time. Walsh made a strategic de cision not to enter the fray and instead channeled resources into developing next generation steel and titanitm hardware. As the resorbables failed to deliver on their promise, Crescordia's market share and reputation grew. But orthopedic surgeons, who'd been hearing for years that resorbables were right around the corner, were eager to use them. Some especially looked for ward to using resorbables on children, so the kids wouldn't have to undergo a second operation for removal of the hardware after the bones healed, a com- 36 IIARVARD BUSINESS RFVIT:W Holding Fast