Claire Cheung was jogging along a quiet trail beside a river when she met Samantha Sage coming the other way. Claire stopped to talk to Samantha, and in conversation, accused Samantha of stealing and shoplifting from Claire's store. Samantha was appalled by the accusations, became irate and struck Claire in the face. Claire was injured, suffering a broken nose and significant bruising. After some time, another jogger came along on the trail and broke up the fight. Claire sued Samantha for battery, and Samantha sued Claire for defamation.

Required: Explain the likely outcome of each lawsuit.