COUNTRY OF JURISDICTION: Philippines

1. X sold his dog to Y on 01 May 2022 with the stipulation that X will deliver the same on 20 May 2022. It turns out that the dog is pregnant and will be having her labour on 19 May 2022, who owns the puppies?

5 points

a. Y because the contract was already perfected on 01 May 2022

b. X because the dog already gave birth before the delivery

c. Both of the parties

d. None of the parties