Determine if the new information would make the analogical argument weaker or stronger. Last year, the Los Angeles Philharmonic put on a great show when they played the musical score from Star Wars. They played it well. This year, they are playing the music from The Godfather. Since I love The Godfather and they played the Star Wars musical score so well, I am sure I will love it. I should get tickets. New information: This year, under a new conductor, the Philharmonic received great reviews for the musical scores of Indiana Jones, Alfred Hitchcock, and The Lord of the Rings.

Stronger

weaker