Question
Gary Sgouros purchased a credit report from Trans-Union's website, hoping to use the high numbers to negotiate a favorable loan at a dealership. How-ever, the
"Gary Sgouros purchased a credit report from Trans-Union's website, hoping to use the high numbers to negotiate a favorable loan at a dealership. How-ever, the credit score he received from TransUnion was 100 points higher than the score pulled by the dealership. Angry that he was unable to arrange an advantageous loan, Sgouros sued TransUnion""under the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Illi-nois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act for misleading consumers by failing to inform them that TransUnion's credit score cal-culation could differ from the algorithms used by a dealership.TransUnion subsequently filed a motion to com-pel arbitration based on the Service Agreement that Sgouros accepted when he ordered the credit score report from TransUnion. The court acknowledged that clicking a button on a website could suffice as an acceptance of an offer and create a bind-ing contract between two parties. In this case, the court examined the TransUnion website on which Sgouros ordered the credit report.Step 2 of the ordering process contained a scrol-lable window with the words "Service Agreement" at the top. Only three lines of text could be read, with the third line at the bottom chopped horizon-tally but still legible. Buried in the scroll box, there was a provision to arbitrate disputes. The printable version of the Service Agreement contained the provision on page 8 out of 10. Below the scroll box, a paragraph in bold text read:"You understand that by clicking on the "I Accept & Continue to Step 3" button below, you are providing "written instructions" to TransUnion Interactive, Inc. authorizing TransUnion Interac-tive, Inc. to obtain information from your personal credit profile from Experian, Equifax and/or Trans-Union. You authorize TransUnion Interactive, Inc.""to obtain such information solely to confirm your identity and display your credit data to you."To proceed to step 3, Sgouros clicked the but-ton immediately under the bolded paragraph that read, "I Accept & Continue to Step 3." Do you think Sgouros' pressing of the button established acceptance of the Service Agreement and the arbi-tration clause in it? How do you think the court ruled? "
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started