Question
General Situation: Your international firm has decided to do a major procurement of a multi-million dollar Enterprise Resource Planning System (ERPS). This will be a
General Situation: Your international firm has decided to do a major procurement of a multi-million dollar Enterprise Resource Planning System (ERPS). This will be a turn-key operation in which the winning vendor will operate the system and train our IT operators and firm staff before it will then be put up for a re-compete in 10 years.It is now soliciting bids from ERPS firms that would like to win the procurement. In exploring this procurement with potential vendors during an open session, several of the vendors requested that your firm provide some more definitive information of how their bids will be evaluated. You have already shared the basic information processing and transmission requirements that the new system must be able to support.However, the bidding vendors would like specifics of how their proposals will be evaluated.
Model: In response to their request you advise that you will be employing a systems approach to evaluate the proposals, specifically using the Multi-Factor Evaluation Process.The four primary criteria will be Technical, Networking, Cost, and Management. Technical will be evaluated based on the sub-criteria of Hardware, Software, Time Trials, and System Integration. Software (SW) is further broken down into the following sub-sub criteria: Accounting and Finance (Acct/Fin) SW, Marketing (Mkt) SW, Supply Chain Management (SCM) SW and Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Software. Cost will be based on the Initial One-time Cost and the annual cost to run the system for the next 10 years; Networking will be based on Speed and Accuracy; lastly, management will be based on Experience, Responsiveness and Professionalism.
Criteria, Sub-criteria and Sub-Sub criteria weights: You elect to keep the weights proprietary. This is to add some uncertainty to the procurement and also to keep them from gaming the system.
Proposals: Three system integration vendors elect to bid on your proposal.You organize a source selection evaluation board (SSEB) to evaluate the three proposals. The SSEB has members who are experienced engineers and procurement specialists who have managed similar projects and provided the requisite inputs on scores and the weights of criteria and sub-criteria. Their scores on the respective sub-criteria are shown below along with the weights for each criteria and sub-criteria.
Criteria Weights: Technical (.2); Cost (.4); Networking (.1); Management (.3)
Sub-criteria Weights:
Technical - Hardware (.2); Software (.3); Systems Integration (.2); Time Trials (.3)
Cost -One Time Purchase (.3) ;Annual cost for each of the 10 years (.7)
Networking - Speed (.4); Accuracy (.3); Reliability (.3);
Management - Experience (.4); Responsiveness (.3); Professionalism (.3)
Sub-Sub Criteria Weights:
Acc't/Fin.3
Mkt.2
SCM.2
CRM.3
Requirements: (a) Use the MFEP to evaluate the three proposals using the scores provided to you from your SSEB (below); (b) Advise whether or not it is a robust or sensitive solution; and lastly, (c) if sensitive indicate what qualitative factors would you recommend be considered before a final decision is made and a vendor selected. Ensure that you show all work so that if a math error is made you can receive partial credit for your work (i.e. ensure that you have an audit trail with steps so that I can see what you have done clearly).
Scores from the SSEBVendor AVendor BVendor C
Hardware908080
Acc't/Fin SW70 8090
Mkt SW907080
SCM SW806070
CRM SW907080
Systems Integration809090
Time Trials809080
One time purchase cost809085
Annual Cost909590
Speed708075
Accuracy808070
Reliability908590
Experience959090
Responsiveness959080
Professionalism809095
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started