Hello tutors, I need help with my THE LAW ON OBLIGATION AND CONTRACTS assignment so I would really appreciate it if you can help me.

CASE:

A road inside a private subdivision has been used even by non-residents because it provides the shortest route to the main road. The subdivision developer has tolerated the public's use of the road. Subsequently, the developer decided to close the road from 5:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. following several complaints from subdivision residents of the noise from the motorists. Heeding the clamor of motorists, the city government urged the developer to open the road 24-7 arguing that the road has been customarily used by the public, as such, the developer has no right to close the road on certain hours. Further, the city government filed a case to compel the developer to do so. The developer turns to you for advice, asking you if the subdivision has an obligation not to close the road on certain hours. What is your advice? Give your legal basis.

This format is highly recommended for the case above

Categorical answer:

Legal basis:

Application on the given set of facts:

Brief conclusion:

This is a case from the Philippines, so you need the articles or provision from the country stated, kindly go here for the reference of the said provisions: (Article 1156 to Article 1206)

https://www.chanrobles.com/civilcodeofthephilippinesbook4.htm