Help create a counter argument for the rival coaches of why susie cannot compete

I support Susie Smith's right to participate in track and field at UMASS despite her prosthetic legs. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits discrimination against individuals with disabilities and requires reasonable accommodations to ensure equal opportunities in various aspects of life, including sports.

Firstly, Susie's prosthetic legs are vital tools that enable her to engage in athletic activities. Denying her the chance to compete would be a violation of the ADA, as it would discriminate against her based on her disability. The ADA mandates that individuals with disabilities receive reasonable accommodations to ensure they have equal access to opportunities. In Susie's case, using prosthetic legs is a reasonable accommodation that allows her to participate on an equal footing with her peers.

Secondly, banning Susie from competition based on the argument of unfair advantage overlooks the unique challenges she faces as an athlete with a disability. While prosthetic legs may offer certain biomechanical benefits, they also present their own set of limitations and difficulties. Susie has endured significant physical and emotional struggles due to her accident, and she should not be penalized for using prosthetic legs to continue pursuing her passion for athletics.

Furthermore, the NCAA's decision to assess such cases individually recognizes the need for tailored evaluations rather than broad prohibitions. This approach allows for consideration of factors such as the type of disability, the specific sport involved, and the potential impact on competitive fairness.

In conclusion, denying Susie the opportunity to compete in track and field at UMASS would contravene her rights under the ADA and would unfairly discriminate against her based on her disability. Instead, Susie should be permitted to compete with reasonable accommodations, ensuring she has equal access to athletic opportunities and can pursue her sporting passion like any other student-athlete.

References:

1. Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, Pub. L. No. 101-336, 104 Stat. 327.
2. NCAA Inclusion of Student-Athletes with Disabilities Policy.