Question
Here is the situation: Phoenix's Marty Mayor is known for his hard-line policies, which often draw protests and protesters. During Monday's city council meeting, a
Here is the situation:
Phoenix's Marty Mayor is known for his hard-line policies, which often draw protests and protesters. During Monday's city council meeting, a group of protesters gathers on the sidewalk outside the council chambers. They chant, "Impeach Marty Mayor!" and carry signs that state the same.
Inside the meeting, Peter Protester sits quietly, waiting his turn to address the city council during the "call to the audience" part of the meeting. When his name is called, Peter addresses the mayor and council and says, "Ladies and gentlemen, this mayor's policies are f*** racist."
Marty Mayor interrupts Peter and says, "Mr. Protester, if you use profanity one more time, I will have you arrested for disturbing the peace."
Peter continues, "This is just another example of his heavy f*** handed f*** fascist f*** policies."
Marty Mayor orders the police officers who are in the chambers to arrest Peter. He also tells the police to clear the sidewalk of protesters outside the meeting, and charge anybody who remains with trespass.
This creates quite a stir, and Ace Reporter is getting lots of calls at his desk in the Phoenix Flyer Newspaper newsroom.
One of the calls is from Ace's best police source. When Ace sees who the call is from, he records the conversation without telling the caller. The source tells Ace that Marty Mayor is in an especially foul mood because he and his wife are getting a divorce, and that his wife got an STD from someone she was having an affair with. The source says the information is contained in the divorce court filing.
Questions-
1.Will the prosecution against Peter for using foul language and disturbing the peace succeed? Why or why not? Use IRAC
2.Are the police within their rights to clear the sidewalk and threaten the protesters with arrest for trespassing? Why or why not? Use IRAC.
3.If Ace is charged with unlawfully recording the phone call with the source, will the prosecution succeed? Why or why not? Use IRAC.
4.Would any additional regulations apply to Ace's covert recording if he worked for a TV station, rather than a newspaper, and he planned to use an audio clip of the recording in his news story? Just explain your answer in a couple of lines without using IRAC.
5.If the police demand to know who Ace's source is, will they succeed in compelling him to disclose the identity? Just explain your answer in a couple of lines without using IRAC.
6.If Marty Mayor's Wife sues Ace Reporter, what lawsuit would she likely file and would it be successful? Why or why not? Use IRAC.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started