Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Hi, please I need help with an assignment for accounting. Case 3-5 Walmart Inventory Shrinkage (a GVV Case) The facts of this case are from

Hi, please I need help with an assignment for accounting. Case 3-5 Walmart Inventory Shrinkage (a GVV Case) The facts of this case are from the Walmart shrinkage fraud discussed in an article in The Nation on June 11, 2014. "Literary license" has been exercised for the purpose of emphasizing important issues related to organizational ethics at Walmart. Any resemblance to actual people and events is coincidental.1 Shane O'Hara always tried to do the right thing. He was in touch with his values and always tried to act in accordance with them, even when the going got tough. But, nothing prepared him for the ordeal he would face as a Walmart veteran and the new store manager in Atomic City, Idaho. In 2013, Shane was contacted by Jeffrey Cook, the regional manager, and told he was being transferred to the Atomic City store in order to reduce the troubled store's high rate of "shrinkage"defined as the value of goods that are stolen or otherwise lostto levels deemed acceptable by the company's senior managers for the region. As a result of fierce competition, profit margins in retail can be razor thin, making shrinkage a potentsometimes criticalfactor in profitability. Historically, Walmart had a relatively low rate of about 0.8 percent of sales. The industry average was 1 percent. Prior to his arrival at the Atomic City store, Shane had heard the store had shrinkage losses as high as $2 million or morea sizable hit to its bottom line. There had even been talk of closing the store altogether. He knew the pressure was on to keep the store open, save the jobs of 40 people, and cut losses so that the regional manager could earn a bonus. It didn't hurt that he would qualify for a bonus as well, so long as the shrinkage rate was cut by more than two-thirds. Shane did what he could to tighten systems and controls. He managed to convince Cook to hire an "asset-protection manager" for the store. The asset-protection program handles shrink, safety, and security at each of its stores. The program worked. Not only did shrinkage decline but other forms of loss, including changing price tags on items of clothing, were significantly reduced. However, it didn't seem to be enough to satisfy Cook and top management. During the last days of August 2013, Shane's annual inventory audit showed a massive reduction in the store's shrinkage rate that surprised even him: Page 182down to less than $80,000 from roughly $800,000 the previous year. He had no explanation for it, but was sure the numbers had been doctored in some way. During the remainder of 2013, a number of high-level managers departed from the company. Cindy Rondel, the head of Walmart's Idaho operations, retired; so did her superior, Larry Brooks. Walmart's regional asset-protection manager for Idaho, who was intimately involved with inventory tracking in the state, was fired as well. Shane wondered if he was next. Shane decided to contact Cook to discuss his concerns. Cook explained why the shrinkage rate had shrunk so much by passing it off as improper accounting at the Atomic City store that had been corrected. He told Shane that an investigation would begin immediately and he was suspended with pay until it was completed. Shane was in shock. He knew the allegations weren't true. He sensed he might become the fall guy for the fraud. Shane managed to discretely talk about his situation with another store manager in the Atomic City area. That manager said she had been the target of a similar investigation the year before. In her case, she had discovered how the fraud was carried out and the numbers were doctored, but she had told no oneuntil now. She explained to Shane that the fraud involved simply declaring that missing items were not in fact missing. She went on to say you could count clothing items in the store and if the on-hand count was offas in, you were supposed to have 12 but you only had 10you could explain that the other 2 were in a bin where clothing had been tried on by customers, not bought, and left in the dressing room often with creases that had to be cleaned before re-tagging the clothing for sale. So, even though some items may have been stolen, they were still counted as part of inventory. There was little or no shrinkage to account for. At this point Shane did not know what his next step should be. He needed to protect his good name and reputation. But what steps should he take? That was the question. Questions: 1.) What are the ethical issues in this case, and who is being affected? 2.)What would you do in this situation? 3.) Do you think what Shane did was whistleblowing? 4.) Explain what is meant by whistleblowing? Include: *An introduction stating the purpose/intent of the paper. *The body of the paper will be derived from the assignment itself, and it will be properly subdivided into sections based upon what the paper must address. *The conclusion will summarize the previously presented content. *Reference with intext citation

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Accounting

Authors: Lew Edwards, John Medlin, Keryn Chalmers, Andreas Hellmann, Claire Beattie, Jodie Maxfield, John Hoggett

9th edition

1118608224, 1118608227, 730323994, 9780730323990, 730319172, 9780730319177, 978-1118608227

More Books

Students also viewed these Accounting questions