Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Hi tutor, this is my 3rd ask for this question. I really suffer!! First, I know my answer already. I just don't know which case

Hi tutor, this is my 3rd ask for this question. I really suffer!!

First, I know my answer already. I just don't know which case relevant / support my answer fully.

Can tutor please help me find the case which support my answer.

But : I only want the case exist in my textbook, which is : " Business Law - James 2022 - 6th edition" . Thank you!

My issue:

I need in text citation suggestion, for example, suggest a chapter for me to find out the statement written by author that is answer my case study question.

Also, I need to have ONLY cases exist in the textbook I mentioned above- which can support my answer.

My question for this case study:

1) Is the Product Safety Issue ( the paint used high lead content ) is suppose to be a "warranty" or " condition" or "intermediate term". If it is a intermediate term - then is it the plaintiff can terminate the contract ?

2) The late delivery => is it a direct loss to plantiff ?

3) When "Robert tells her there are no particular bans that apply to this range of toy cars" and " Robert says he knew about that ban, but he did not think it applied to this particular range of toy cars" => is this statement depict the fraudulent misrepresentation ?

4) Koufos v C Czarnikow Ltd; The Heron II [1969] 1 AC 350 => is this case good for arguing the late delivery, which is direct loss for Cass ?

Answer the question B) only please !! Please focus on question B)

Note: Maybe you can read the textbook, it only range from chapter 7 to chapter 9.

Thank you tutor ! Please save me

image text in transcribed
PROBLEM SCENARIO: Robert imports and sells children's toys throughout New South Wales, and so gets a booth to display the children's toys at the trade show held in Sydney in September 2023. Cassandra, who owns a small gift store in Parramatta, was interested in buying children's toys for sale at her gift store. She went to the trade show. Whilst at the trade show, Cassandra visited Robert's display booth. Cassandratells Robert that she is looking for children's toys for sale at her gift shop during the Christmas season. Robert shows her a range of remote-control toy cars. Robert assures Cassandra that this product is sure to be popular with kids and make a perfect gift at any time of the year. Cassandra thinks that these toy cars will sell well in her store, particularly between the months October and December, just before Christmas. When she looks at the price list and finds the toy cars are $50 each, she is disappointed as she thinks she will not be able to make enough profit if she buys them at that price. She asks Robert whether he would be interested in selling her the toy cars at $30 each. Robert says this price would only be alright if Cassandra buys bulk of 500 cars. After some consideration Cassandra decides she will order 500 toy cars at $30 each. Before signing the sales order, Cassandra remembers that some toy cars have been banned by Product Safety Australia as they do not comply with child safety standards. She asks Robert about this and Robert tells her there are no particular bans that apply to this range of toy cars. Cassandra then signs the sales order, which states that the toy cars will be delivered within 3 weeks of the order being signed. As it turns out, there is a strike by workers at the manufacturer's toy factory. The factory is shut Hown for two weeks and work comes to a stop. The toy cars are not delivered until late December, after the Christmas selling season is over. Further only 300 toy cars are delivered. Robert insists that Cassandrawill have to pay $50 each for them because the number is smaller than was agreed to. However, Cassandra does not want to accept delivery, or to pay for the toy cars at all. Cassandra doesn't think they will sell now because the season is over. More seriously, she has discovered that the toy cars are in fact of a kind that is banned by Product Safety Australia because the paint used has a high lead content and is therefore a risk to children. Robert says he knew about that ban, but he did not think it applied to this particular range of toy cars. (a) Discuss whether a binding contract was formed at the trade show (i.e., identify the steps of ontract formation in the above facts).(5 marks) (b) Is Cassandra required to accept the toy cars and pay for them under contract law? Why or why not? In your answer you should consider whether Cassandra has any grounds to avoid performing her part of the agreement. (10 marks)

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image_2

Step: 3

blur-text-image_3

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

The Legal Environment Of Business A Managerial Approach Theory To Practice

Authors: Sean Melvin, Enrique Guerra-Pujol

4th Edition

1260247805, 978-1260247800

More Books

Students also viewed these Law questions

Question

Find a nice formula for x] dx,b> 0

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

2. How do these vengeful heroes exorcise their daemons?

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

Computing Federal Income Tax

Answered: 1 week ago