Question
In February 1997, a trucking company, and Maker, a manufacturer, negotiated an agreement under which Carrier promised to provide for two years all the transportation
In February 1997, a trucking company, and Maker, a manufacturer, negotiated an agreement under which Carrier promised to provide for two years all the transportation services required by Maker in exchange for monthly payments based on the number of packages transported. In response to Carrier's concerns over proposed legislation that would restrict its ability to use more efficient "triple-trailer"" trucks, the parties agreed that Carrier could terminate the contract if such legislation were enacted. No such law was ever passed.
Carrier drafted a document embodying the agreed terms and, on March 1, 1997, sent two signed copies to Maker with a request that Maker sign and return one copy. Although Maker did not sign the document, the parties immediately began doing business according to its terms. During the next six months, Maker paid all of Carrier's monthly invoices on time. During the same period, Carrier declined two potentially lucrative offers from other manufacturers because performance of the agreement with Maker required most of Carrier's capacity.
In September 1997, Maker began to have concerns about the cost of Carrier's service. Maker sent a letter to Transport, one of Carrier's competitors, describing Maker's needs, Maker's agreement with Carrier, and the amount charged by Carrier. Transport offered to provide comparable transportation services at a lower cost. On September 20, Maker sent a fax to Carrier stating that Maker would no longer use Carrier's services as of November 1. Carrier responded with a fax to Maker which stated that Maker had no right to terminate the contract. On September 21, Maker suspended all business with Carrier and began doing business with Transport. Maker also refused to pay an invoice submitted by Carrier for transportation services rendered in September.
What, if any, rights and remedies does Carrier have against Maker? Discuss.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started