Jim owns a lawn care service. He would like to obtain a new heavy duty trailer to haul his equipment and materials from job to job. Hes found one that will suit his needs. The purchase price is $8,500. Jim is in a 28% tax bracket and sales taxes are 5%. The cost of capital for Jim to purchase the trailer is 8%. The trailer qualifies for 5 year MACRS depreciation method. Jim intends on using the equipment for 60 months. The salvage value of the trailer at the end of the use period is $4500. Jim has also found a dealer that is willing to lease the trailer to him for 60 months for $150 per month. The lease payments would be due at the beginning of the month. Determine if Jim should lease or buy this trailer.

What is the Book Value at the end of year 5?

	$1,785
	$1,028

$1,785

What is the total depreciation benefit [PW(8%)]?

$7,897

$1,839

What is the taxable gains or (loss) tax on the sale of the equipment?

$972

$1260

What is the PW of the net proceeds from the sale?

$3,472

$2,401

What is the total cost of the buy decision?

$4,685

$4,512

Should Jim lease or buy this trailer?

	Lease
	Buy

$1,028

What is the total economic depreciation benefit for all 5 years? (include taxes)

	End of Year		5 year MACRS	Depreciation Benefit	Tax Benefit @28% tax rate	PW (8%)
	1		20%
	2		32%
	3		19.2%
	4		11.52%
	5		5.76%
	Total Sum
		$6,521

$7,897