Jim, the manager of an apartment complex owned by Osric, rented an apartment to Cynthia. A few weeks later, Cynthia complained that she had no hot water. Jim hired Cooper Plumbing to fix the hot water, but they did not fix it. A few days later, Cynthia moved out because she had no hot water. She sues Osric and Jim for breach of contract. Who is liable?

A. Hot water is a luxury, so Cynthia should get used to cold baths.

B. Jim is personally liable for this breach of contract.

C. Osric is liable, but Jim is not.

D. Jim is liable, but Osric is not.

E. Neither Jim nor Osric is liable to Cynthia.