Question
Kayla is a legal secretary for the law firm of Donovan and Smith in Barbados. As part of her job, the firm requires her to
Kayla is a legal secretary for the law firm of Donovan and Smith in Barbados. As part of her job, the firm requires her to visit various places to deliver documents to defendants. Kayla goes to Baron Motors' car dealership and delivers some documents to Devin, the sales manager, who is being sued by Donovan and Smith. Baron Motors posts a sign behind the sales counter stating that it "does not accept liability for injuries suffered on the premises however caused." However, the sign is not prominent and staff do not call it to customers' attention. Devin becomes angry with the content of the documents and chased Kayla through the dealership, shouting at her and waving his arms. Devin catches up with Kayla at the door of her car and prevents her from getting in the car and leaving, shouting that he will call the police to have her arrested. After a few minutes of shouting, the dealership owner, Sarah, pulls Devin away from Kayla's car and Kayla leaves. While Devin is ranting in the parking lot, Alyssa, an unemployed person of no specified abode passing through the property, pauses in the middle of the aisle to gawk at Devin. As she stands there, Amy, a mechanic at the dealership, drives a carbelonging to a customer out of a maintenance bay toward a parking space. Amy is momentarily confused by the manual transmission and accidentally puts the car in the wrong gear, causing it to leap forward and strike Alyssa. Alyssa suffers two broken legs and a broken spine; her physicians believe she will never walk again. The customer to whom the car belongs, David, is waiting in the lobby for his repairs to be finished when he watches Alyssa get run down by his car. David runs outside to assist but trips over a container of gas that Michael, a salesman, has left outside when he fills up a new car that had arrived that day. The trip and fall is relatively minor, but the gas can spills, pooling gasoline around David. When David gets up, his steel-toed boots, whose leather was damaged, exposing the metal, scrapes the asphalt, creating sparks, which ignite the gasoline and cause the gas container to explode. David is badly burned and spends significant time home from work as he recovers. Donovan and Smith file lawsuits on behalf of Kayla against Devin for assault, battery, and false imprisonment; on behalf of Alyssa against Sarah and Amy for negligence; and on behalf of David against Sarah for nuisance and under an occupiers' liability theory. Questions: 1. For this question, and this question only, you are a clerk for a judge on the Court of Justice. Write a draft judgment for the court in the case arising from Kayla's claim against Devin. In your judgment, critically discuss the doctrine that would govern Kayla's assault, battery, and false imprisonment claims and any defenses Devin could assert. 2. Advise Sarah on her liability to David. You should assume that damage to David's car constitutes an "invasion of an interest in property" sufficient to satisfy that hurdle of private nuisance; however, you should not assume that it constitutes an "injury to property" sufficient to prove private nuisance standing alone. You should also analyze whether the outcome is different under commonlaw doctrines and any applicable statutes 3. Evaluate Alyssa's legal rights with regard to Sarah and Amy
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started