Lucas Matsen's sued Baker Public School District for suspending him due to wearing a T-

shirt that had an image of a gun and wording "Own Guns-2nd Am. and stop SchoolVioloence!"

The school was bound by the district policy which prohibited the student from wearing

accessories and clothes which display the symbol of violence. According to the principal, the

school had been featured with several issues which included shooting with another school 5 miles away. Student was suspended from school. He then sued the school for violating his 1st amendments rights.

Representing the defendant, Baker public School District. What would the Standards of Review be in a memorandum of law in support for summary judgment?