Question
Madam Neo is a 65-year-old homemaker who is widowed. Ever since her husband passed on, Madam Neo has put most of her life savings in
Madam Neo is a 65-year-old homemaker who is widowed. Ever since her husband passed on, Madam Neo has put most of her life savings in fixed deposits. Occasionally, she speculates in stocks when she receives tips from her neighbors. However, she now wants to invest more conservatively so that she can pay for her grandchildren's college education. The following is a translated excerpt from the Mandarin conversation between Madam Neo and Edwin:
Madam Neo: "Wow, I wasn't expecting you to be so young. Do you have much experience managing portfolios?"
Edwin: "Don't worry. I graduated top of my class and passed the CFA level I exam, which is one of the world's most rigorous professional qualifying exams for investment. So, I'm more qualified than most young people my age in this job."
Madam Neo: "That's reassuring to know. I heard from my friends that your bank offers this oil-linked note that pays 10% interest a year? That's much higher than one I'm currently getting from my fixed deposits. My energy stocks have been doing so poorly too. I need to invest in something new."
Edwin: "You betcha. It's our hottest productI highly recommend it."
Edwin offers Madam Neo a brochure on the structured note. However, the brochure is in English, a language in which Madam Neo is not proficient. So Edwin provides an oral summary of the product in Mandarin, explaining to Madam Neo that the product's return is linked to the performance of a basket of oil-futures indexes. Although Edwin does not translate the full product terms and conditions, which is in fine print, he does caution Madam Neo that the 10% annual interest is not guaranteed. Also, while principal is fully protected if the note is held to maturity, Edwin cautions that there will be a penalty for early redemption of the note, which will mature in 7 years. He also tells Madam Neo that, since the product was launched three years ago, the requirements for interest payment have been met every year. Madam Neo is neither sure what oil futures are nor how they work, but she decides to invest USD 100,000 into the note anyway. Edwin promptly executes the transaction at Madam Neo's request.
A year later, Madam Neo is shocked when she does not receive any payments from the structured note. She learns from her friends that a pandemic has curtailed all travel and caused oil prices to fall off a cliff, and prices are likely to stay depressed with no end in sight. Panicked, Madam Neo calls Edwin on his mobile phone because she could not reach him on his office phone and instructs him to immediately redeem the structured note and place the redemption proceeds in a fixed deposit instead. Edwin suggests that Madam Neo consider the full costs before proceeding, but Madam Neo says she is already late for a manicure appointment and tells Edwin to act on it immediately. Even though Edwin was not able to record the conversation, he redeemed the note for her because of the urgency of the request.
Several weeks later, Madam Neo learns that the redemption proceeds is only USD 60,000. She calls Edwin again, demanding an explanation. Edwin reminds her that he had warned her about the early redemption penalty when Madam Neo was considering the product. Madam Neo claims that she is aware of the penalty but not how significant the penalty would be. She also argues that she was under the impression that the product is low-risk because Edwin told her there had been consistent prior payouts previously.
Outraged, Madam Neo files a complaint against Edwin. The regulator opens an investigation and considers Madam Neos's case a strong one, as she is a "vulnerable client" in the eyes of the law. Vulnerable clients are individuals who meet two of the following criteria: aged 62 years or older; not proficient in English; have below high-school certification or equivalent academic qualifications.
Edwin tells his supervisor Jonathan that he is not aware of the "vulnerable client" condition as this is not part of the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct. Jonathan tells Edwin that the "vulnerable client" condition is specified in the DBS employee handbook, and that by signing and submitting the employee acknowledgement page during his first week at DBS, Edwin had acknowledged his understanding of the "vulnerable client" condition.
Question:
Specify at most five (5) violations of the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct. State clearly who violated the Code and Standards, which specific Standard or part of the Standard has been violated, and present evidence from the case to support your answer. Each non-violation that has been incorrectly identified as a violation will be penalized, as will any violations in excess of five, including correct ones.
Step by Step Solution
3.37 Rating (156 Votes )
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Violation by Edwin Standard IB Independence and Objectivity Edwin violated the Standard IB by recommending the oillinked note without fully informing ...Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started