$$ Moving to another question will save this response.

Question $1$

Why did it matter, in the case, whether Doughty was an independent contractor or an employee at the time of the accident?

Because if Doughty was an employee, Beta would not be liable, but if he was an independent contractor, Beta would be liable.

Because if Doughty was an employee, Beta would be liable, but if he was an independent contractor, Beta would not be liable.