Question
Northern Cross Computer Systems Pty Ltd (NCCS), an IT services and consulting firm in Melbourne, employs Beatrice as an IT specialist. NCCS's main business is
Northern Cross Computer Systems Pty Ltd (NCCS), an IT services and consulting firm in
Melbourne, employs Beatrice as an IT specialist. NCCS's main business is in Victoria. Beatrice
held a 40% shareholding in NCCS that she had gradually accumulated over the course of her
employment (18 years). In June 2016, Beatrice entered into a share sale agreement with NCCS
to sell her shares to Indigo Pty Ltd. The agreement provided for payment of $3.5 million to
Beatrice and for her to continue as an employee of NCCS with a non-compete restraint in favour
of NCCS for a period of eight years (the Restraint Period). The contract stated that during the
Restraint Period, she must not 'carry on, engage in or have any involvement in the Restricted
Business'.
'Restricted Business' was defined as 'any business which is competitive with, or likely to be
competitive with, the Business at the relevant time during the Restraint Period.' Business was
defined as 'the business of IT procurement and associated IT managed services carried on by the
Company.'
Beatrice is keen to move away from Melbourne to avoid her half-brother, so she gives NCCS one
month's notice (provided in the employment contract), and informs NCCS that she intends to
sign a lucrative contract with Green Connections Pty Ltd (GCPL), an IT company in Darwin.
NCCS's CEO, Jeff, approaches you about Beatrice's conduct, and says that he recently read a
Victorian case from 2017 about this type of thing, and thinks Beatrice is in breach of her
agreement with NCCS in June 2016.
Advise Jeff if NCCS can enforce that agreement and prevent Beatrice from joining GCPL.
Use case law to support your answer.
Note: While you may rely on the course materials on Legality of Object, research is also required for this scenario. Do not discuss any other elements of the
law of contract.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started